Let The Cat Out Of The Bag: Meaning and Origin Revealed

Written by Dayva Segal
Published: February 16, 2023
Share on:

Advertisement


To “let the cat out of the bag” is a colloquial phrase that means to tell some facts that were perhaps a secret beforehand. It can be positive or negative information, and it can be used whether or not you accidentally told the information, or did it on purpose.

Origin Of The Phrase “Let The Cat Out Of The Bag”

There are a few theories as to the origins of the phrase “let the cat out of the bag.” The first is that, in the middle ages, sellers would swindle customers by placing a cat in a bag instead of a pig. When the buyer got home, they would let the cat out, and see they had been tricked. However, this theory doesn’t hold much weight. There would be a big weight difference between a cat and a pig, and getting a cat, or a pig for that matter, into a bag might not be an easy task depending on the temperament of the animal.

Another theory is that the word cat refers to a type of whip used in nautical punishments called a cat-o-nine tails. This whip was kept in a red bag, and it may have been said that the sailor who revealed the crime of another was “letting the cat out of the bag.”

The most likely theory is that if you imagine it, it would simply be impossible to get a cat back into a bag once you let it out, much in the same way that it is impossible to put a secret back once it is let out.

The first published written usage of this phrase was in 1760. It appeared in a book review in the London Magazine. However, it was also used in a letter from Johannes Agricola to Martin Luther during the Protestant Reformation in 1530.

Cat in a paper bag

To “let the cat out of the bag” is a colloquial phrase that means to tell some facts that were perhaps a secret beforehand.

©iStock.com/Natalia POGODINA

Examples Of Everday Usage Of The Phrase “Let The Cat Out Of The Bag”

You can use this phrase to refer to any secret that you divulge, whether it is a positive or negative secret or something you meant to tell or told by accident. It can be used in pretty much any context where there is a secret involved, whether it is business, family, friendships, or something else entirely. Once the secret is out, there’s no putting it back!

A Useful Way To Illustrate The Phrase “Let The Cat Out Of The Bag”

This is a fictional story to show a great example of the use of this phrase.

Imagine that you have a friend who is pregnant. She told you but she didn’t want to tell anyone else just yet. You are at a party and you forgot that the pregnancy was a secret. You are talking to your pregnant friend and she is talking about her vacation schedule. “In June, we are going to England!” She exclaims. Then you say “And, then you’re having the baby in September right?” Everyone at the party turns around and gasps. The cat is out of the bag! Now everyone knows that your friend is pregnant.

Woman looking shocked at revealing a secret

A modern day example of letting the cat out of the bag is revealing that your friend is pregnant when it was meant to be a secret.

©iStock.com/DragonImages

A Real-Life Example From Forbes

In May of 2022, an article on the Forbes website described how President Biden said that higher gas prices were a necessary part of shifting to alternative energy sources like solar and wind. The author of the article, Steve Forbes, said that this “confession” was Biden letting the cat out of the bag in regard to this energy industry secret, before going on to explain his thoughts on the matter.

Possible Pros And Cons Of Using The Phrase “Let The Cat Out Of The Bag”

This phrase isn’t really offensive to use on someone who has let out a secret. However, it could be used in a moment of frustration if someone let out a secret that they shouldn’t have. In general, there’s nothing wrong with using this phrase to describe a secret getting out, whether or not you meant for it to come out.

Trying to get a cat into a carrier

Trying to get a cat back into a bag is difficult in a similar way that a secret cannot be unsaid.

©iStock.com/Denis Valakhanovich

Similar Phrases To “Let The Cat Out Of The Bag”

There are a few idioms in the English language that have a similar meaning to “let the cat out of the bag.” However, these phrases don’t have exactly the same meaning, so make sure you understand the meaning before you use them!

  • Spill the beans
  • Give the game away
  • Blow the gaff
  • Blow the lid off

The photo featured at the top of this post is © iStock.com/Ivan Zhaborovskiy


Share on:
About the Author

Dayva is a writer at A-Z Animals primarily covering astrology, animals, and geography. She has over 12 years of experience as a writer, and graduated from Hofstra University in 2007 with a Bachelor of Science in Music and a Minor in French. She has also completed course work in Core Strengths Coaching, Hypnotherapy, and Technical Communication. Dayva lives in the SF Bay Area with her cute but very shy cat, Tula.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

What does the phrase "let the cat out of the bag" mean?

To “let the cat out of the bag” means to tell some facts that were perhaps a secret beforehand.

What are the origins of the phrase "let the cat out of the bag"

One origin theory of the phrase “let the cat out of the bag” comes from the middle ages. Sellers would swindle customers by placing a cat in a bag instead of a pig. When the buyer got home, they would let the cat out, and see they had been tricked.

Another theory is that the word cat refers to a type of whip used in nautical punishments called a cat-o-nine tails. This whip was kept in a red bag, and it may have been said that the sailor who revealed the crime of another was “letting the cat out of the bag.”

The most likely theory is that if you imagine it, it would simply be impossible to get a cat back into a bag once you let it out, much in the same way that it is impossible to put a secret back once it is let out.

What was the first written usage of the phrase "let the cat out of the bag"?

The first published written usage of this phrase was in 1760. It appeared in a book review in the London Magazine. However, it was also used in a letter from Johannes Agricola to Martin Luther during the Protestant Reformation in 1530.

What are phrases with a similar meaning to "let the cat out of the bag"?

Similar phrases to “let the cat out of the bag” include:

  • Spill the beans
  • Give the game away
  • Blow the gaff
  • Blow the lid off

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us? Contact the AZ Animals editorial team.