7 Towns With the Cheapest Gas in Upstate New York

Written by Shreya Agrawal
Published: September 27, 2023
Share on:


Gasoline prices can significantly impact your daily expenses, especially if you rely on a vehicle for transportation. In New York State, gas prices can vary greatly from one town to another. If you’re looking for affordable fuel options, you’re in the right place. In this article, we’ll explore seven towns in New York State with some of the cheapest gas prices.

1. Akron: $3.25 at Western Door

Highway 87 in upstate New York

Highway 87 in upstate New York in summer heading north

©Guy Banville/iStock via Getty Images

Overview: Akron is a small charming village located in Erie County, New York. It is known for its picturesque small-town atmosphere, friendly residents, and affordability. The town also offers easy access to a variety of services, including budget-friendly fuel options.

Western Door Gas Station: The Western Door gas station is a local favorite for its consistently low gas prices. Regular gasoline at just $3.25 per gallon makes it an attractive choice for both Akron residents and travelers passing through. With its convenient location and welcoming atmosphere, Western Door is a reliable stop for affordable fuel.

Local Attractions: Akron is situated near the Akron Falls Park, a scenic spot featuring a picturesque waterfall, picnic areas, and walking trails. The town also hosts community events, including the annual “Akron Pumpkin Hill Festival,” which draws visitors from neighboring areas.

2. Basom: $3.30 at Two Eagles

South Grand Island Bridge

The South Grand Island Bridge spans Niagara river in Upstate New York.

©Ultima_Gaina/iStock via Getty Images

Overview: Basom is a small town in Genesee County, New York. It is known for its rural charm and proximity to natural attractions like the Tonawanda Wildlife Management Area. Basom’s affordability extends to its gas prices, making it an excellent choice for budget-conscious folks.

Two Eagles Gas Station: Two Eagles is a local gas station in Basom that offers regular gasoline at an attractive rate of $3.30 per gallon. It is a go-to spot for residents and travelers looking to save on fuel expenses.

Natural Beauty: Basom is close to the Tonawanda Wildlife Management Area, providing opportunities for birdwatching, hiking, and wildlife photography. The surrounding rural landscape offers a peaceful escape from city life.

3. Limestone: $3.39 (Sassy’s Truck Stop)

Traffic on the Long Island Expressway

Photo of motion blurred traffic on the Long Island Expressway, Suffolk County, New York.

©Joan D Squared/iStock via Getty Images

Overview: Limestone is a town located in Cattaraugus County in western New York. It is a community that values affordability and accessibility.

Sassy’s Truck Stop: Sassy’s Truck Stop in Limestone offers regular gasoline at a competitive price of $3.39 per gallon. This truck stop caters to both local residents and travelers passing through the region. Its friendly service and economical fuel prices make it a preferred choice.

Outdoor Exploration: Limestone’s rural setting is ideal for outdoor exploration. The nearby Allegany State Park has opportunities for hiking, camping, and scenic views. Visitors can also explore the Allegheny National Forest, which is just a short drive away.

4. Liverpool: $3.39 (CITGO)

Bench overlooking the Seneca River

Bench overlooking the Seneca River , leading into Onondaga Lake, in Onondaga Lake Park, Liverpool, New York, with a fisherman Carp fishing in the distance

©DebraMillet/iStock via Getty Images

Overview: Liverpool is a suburb of Syracuse, New York, located in Onondaga County. It is a thriving community with a mix of residential neighborhoods and commercial areas. Liverpool’s proximity to the city as well as its competitive gas prices make it an attractive option for both residents and commuters.

CITGO Gas Station: The CITGO gas station in Liverpool sells regular gasoline at a favorable rate of $3.39 per gallon. Its location near major highways and commuter routes also ensures that many locals benefit from its affordable fuel options.

Convenient Access: Liverpool residents have easy access to the cultural amenities and employment opportunities due to the proximity to Syracuse. Residents also benefit from lower gas prices within their community. The town is also known for the scenic Onondaga Lake Park, which has walking trails and a marina.

5. Staten Island: $3.39 (Shell)

Detail of the Staten Island Ferry Terminal in New York City

Detail of the Staten Island Ferry Terminal in New York City, USA.

©Tiago_Fernandez/iStock via Getty Images

Overview: Staten Island is one of New York City’s five boroughs, located in Richmond County. Despite its urban setting, Staten Island has competitive gas prices compared to other parts of the city, making it an appealing option for residents and visitors.

Shell Gas Station: The Shell gas station on Staten Island sells regular gasoline at a competitive price of $3.39 per gallon. It is a convenient choice for local residents and travelers.

Local Highlights: Staten Island has several attractions such as the Staten Island Zoo, Snug Harbor Cultural Center and Botanical Garden and the Staten Island Ferry, which can take people on stunning views of the Statue of Liberty and Manhattan’s skyline.

6. Sanborn: $3.40 (Bear Clause Trading Post)

Road signage on a snowy afternoon in upstate New York. Route 17 and route 97 near Sands Creek

Hancock, New York – December 12, 2022 : Road signage on a snowy afternoon in upstate New York. Route 17 and route 97 near Sands Creek

©Scott Heaney/iStock via Getty Images

Overview: Sanborn is a town located in Niagara County, New York. It is known for its quiet, rural character and is a part of the broader town of Cambria. Sanborn provides residents with a serene environment.

Bear Clause Trading Post: The Bear Clause Trading Post in Sanborn sells regular gasoline at a competitive price of $3.40 per gallon. It caters to local residents and those exploring the natural beauty of Western New York, including those who are travelling to or from Niagara Falls.

Natural Wonders: Sanborn is surrounded by the scenic landscapes of Niagara County, including Niagara Falls, the Niagara Wine Trail, and hiking trails along the Niagara Escarpment. The town’s proximity to these attractions makes it an ideal starting point for outdoor adventures.

7. Clay: $3.45 (BJ’s)

Warehouse storage near construction site of mobile trailer park with infrastructure onsite concrete slab grade foundation support works in Upstate New York

Warehouse storage near construction site of mobile trailer park with infrastructure onsite concrete slab grade foundation support works in Upstate New York. Aerial trailer park concrete road, sewer

©TrongNguyen/iStock via Getty Images

Overview: Clay is a town in Onondaga County, New York, and is situated in the Syracuse metropolitan area. The town has a suburban lifestyle, but still has access to city amenities. While gas prices may be slightly higher than in some other towns on this list, Clay still provides competitive options for budget-conscious people.

BJ’s Gas Station: The BJ’s gas station in Clay sells regular gasoline at an affordable price of $3.45 per gallon.

Shopping and Recreation: Clay is home to the Great Northern Mall, which has several shopping and dining options. The town’s recreational opportunities also include parks, golf courses, and easy access to Onondaga Lake Park.

Influences on Gas Prices in New York

Gas prices can be influenced by a multitude of factors. Understanding these factors can help consumers better comprehend the fluctuations in fuel prices.

1. Crude Oil Prices

The price of crude oil on the global market is one of the most significant factors affecting gas prices. As New York relies heavily on oil for gasoline production, any fluctuations in global crude oil prices can directly impact what motorists pay at the pump. The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) plays a pivotal role in global oil production. OPEC’s decisions to increase or decrease oil production can influence crude oil prices, which, in turn, affects gas prices in New York.

2. Local and State Taxes

New York imposes state and local taxes on gasoline sales. These taxes can vary by county, leading to differences in gas prices from one region to another within the state. Changes in state or local tax rates can lead to fluctuations in gas prices.

3. Transportation Costs

The costs associated with transporting gasoline from refineries to distribution centers and gas stations can impact prices. These expenses include transportation fees, trucking costs, and maintenance of infrastructure. New York does not have major oil refineries, so it often imports gasoline from other states and regions. These transportation costs can vary depending on the distance and mode of transportation.

4. Supply and Demand

Gasoline demand tends to increase during the summer months due to vacations and travel. Seasonal variations in demand can lead to higher gas prices during peak travel seasons. The demand for gasoline can also fluctuate based on local factors such as population density, employment rates, and commuting patterns. Thus, high-demand areas may experience higher gas prices.

5. Environmental Regulations

New York, like many states, requires the use of reformulated gasoline in some areas to reduce air pollution. However, producing reformulated gasoline can be more expensive. Thus, it can contribute to higher gas prices in affected regions.

6. Competition among Gas Stations

Areas with numerous gas stations often have more competitive pricing. Gas stations may employ pricing strategies to attract customers, such as offering discounts, loyalty programs, or cashback promotions. Thus, these strategies can lead to variations in gas prices.

7. Economic Factors

The state of the economy, including factors like inflation and unemployment, can also affect consumer spending and, in turn, gasoline demand. Economic downturns can lead to reduced gasoline consumption and potentially lower prices. As crude oil is traded globally, fluctuations in currency exchange rates also can impact the price of oil. A weaker U.S. dollar, for example, can lead to higher crude oil prices and, consequently, higher gas prices.

8. Natural Disasters and Geopolitical Events

Natural disasters such as hurricanes can also disrupt oil production and refining facilities, leading to supply shortages and higher gas prices. Political instability and conflicts in oil-producing regions can also disrupt the supply chain and lead to uncertainty in the global oil market.

9. Fuel Blend Requirements

New York may require different fuel blends in certain areas to address air quality concerns. These specialized blends can be costlier to produce and may contribute to price variations.

Understanding this complex interplay of factors can help consumers make informed decisions about when and where to purchase gasoline in New York. Staying informed about global oil market trends, local tax changes, and regional supply and demand dynamics is therefore very important.

Finding the Best Gas Prices

Gas prices can fluctuate frequently, influenced by factors such as global oil prices, supply and demand, and local competition among gas stations, as mentioned above. To secure the best gas prices in these towns and elsewhere in New York State, remember the following tips:

Use Gas Price Comparison Apps

Utilize smartphone apps and websites that track and compare gas prices in your area. These tools can help you locate the most cost-effective options quickly.

Join Rewards Programs

Many gas station chains offer rewards programs that provide discounts or cashback on fuel purchases. Signing up for these programs can lead to long-term savings.

Time Your Fill-Ups

Gas prices can often change during the week. Keep an eye on price trends in your area and plan to fill up your tank when prices are lower.

Consider Fuel-Efficient Vehicles

If you frequently commute or travel, investing in a fuel-efficient vehicle can lead to long-term savings on gas.

The photo featured at the top of this post is © Kirkikis/iStock via Getty Images

Share on:
About the Author

Shreya is a climate scientist. She also studies paleontology and evolutionary biology. She enjoys reading all kinds of literature and listening to rock music in her free time.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us? Contact the AZ Animals editorial team.