The 4 Best Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holders

Written by Susan Olayode
Updated: March 13, 2023
© g215/Shutterstock.com

Advertisement


This post may contain affiliate links to our partners like Chewy, Amazon, and others. Purchasing through these helps us further the A-Z Animals mission to educate about the world's species.

There are two types of cats in this world, those that don’t care and those that will wreak havoc on your toilet paper. This review is for cat parents of the latter. It can be frustrating cleaning up the strips or discovering that you’ve run out because your cat got there first.

Your cat might attack your toilet roll because it’s fun, or they’re practicing hunting. It could also be because they have gum pain and need something soft to gnaw on. Whatever the reason, most cat parents take measures to protect their toilet paper. One of those is getting cat-proof toilet paper holders.

If you’re in the market for a cat-proof toilet paper holder, we can help. We evaluated the top-rated versions and ranked and rated the very best. From there, it should be easier for you to find one that will work for your household.

So, without further ado, here are the best cat-proof toilet paper holders.

  1. YOMESTE Wall-Mounted Waterproof Paper Holder Bathroom Paper Roll Holder
    • Simple, yet lovely waterproof design
    • Easy to install
    • Effectively keeps cats out of your toilet paper
    • The design allows you to see when you're running out of toilet paper
    • Inexpensive and durable
    Check Amazon
  2. yeavs Toilet Paper Holder with Phone Shelf and Waterproof Cover
    • Features a sleek, modern design
    • Cat-resistant, rust-resistant, and easy to install
    • Made of stainless steel
    • Has a top shelf that can double as a cell phone holder
    • Has high-quality finishes such as "deburred" edges
    Check Amazon
  3. YOHOM Wall-Mounted Toilet Paper Roll Holder with Shelf and Drawer
    • Features a shelf and a drawer to store feminine hygiene products
    • Waterproof, cat-proof, and dust-proof
    • Constructed of plastic
    • Compact, modern design
    • Includes a backup adhesive sticker in case you choose to move the holder
    Check Amazon
  4. JunSun Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holder Stainless Steel Brushed Nickel
    • The elegant design effectively keeps cats out
    • The acrylic sides allow you to see how much toilet paper you have left
    • Nickel finish on stainless steel prevents scratches
    • Virtually waterproof
    • Rustproof
    Check Amazon

A-Z-Animals’ Top Picks for the Best Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holders

#1 Best Overall: YOMESTE Wall-Mounted Waterproof Paper Holder Bathroom Paper Roll Holder

The #1 best overall cat-proof toilet paper holder is the YOMESTE Wall-Mounted Waterproof Paper Holder Bathroom Paper Roll Holder. We picked this option for its simple but lovely aesthetics, ease of installation, and transparency. Most of all, your cat won’t get access to the toilet roll with it.

Reviewers appreciated that you can actually see when you’re running out of paper with this and replace it. This cat-proof toilet paper holder is also great for smaller bathrooms and is cheap and durable. It is waterproof and made from material that is easy to clean.

You don’t have to worry about rust when you buy the YOMESTE Wall-Mounted Waterproof Paper Holder Bathroom Paper Roll Holder. It is also easy to take off this holder and replace the tissue inside. This toilet paper holder also doesn’t come with any sharp edges that can injure you during use.

While some users reported that it is, indeed, cat-proof, others said that this holder won’t accommodate larger rolls of toilet paper.

Pros and Cons of the YOMESTE Wall-Mounted Waterproof Paper Holder Bathroom Paper Roll Holder

ProsCons
This wall-mounted toilet paper holder is attractive, easy to install, transparent, and cat-proof.It won’t accommodate larger rolls of toilet paper.
You can see when you’re running out of paper.
It’s inexpensive, durable, and waterproof as well as being easy to clean.
It’s rust-proof.
Replacing the tissue is easy and there are no sharp edges that could injure you.
Best Overall
YOMESTE Wall-Mounted Waterproof Paper Holder Bathroom Paper Roll Holder
  • Simple, yet lovely waterproof design
  • Easy to install
  • Effectively keeps cats out of your toilet paper
  • The design allows you to see when you're running out of toilet paper
  • Inexpensive and durable
Check Amazon

2. Best for Aesthetics: YEAVS Toilet Paper Holder with Phone Shelf and Waterproof Cover

The YEAVS Toilet Paper Holder with Phone Shelf and Waterproof Cover is sleek, modern, and, most of all, cat-resistant. It’ll bring a touch of class to your bathroom aesthetic. We also love that this toilet paper holder is easy to install.

Made of high-quality stainless steel, this holder is corrosion-resistant and won’t rust. It is also water-resistant and will stop your roll from getting wet. A great top-shelf means this holder can double as a cell phone holder alongside other small items.

You’ll love that the edges are deburred, preventing you from getting cuts and injuries. It is, however, a bit more expensive but with these features, we say it is worth it.

One review reported that their cats were still able to destroy the edges of the roll but not unfurl it. Also, some reviewers said that oversized rolls of toilet paper won’t fit.

Pros and Cons of the YEAVS Toilet Paper Holder with Phone Shelf and Waterproof Cover

ProsCons
This toilet paper holder with phone shelf and waterproof cover is sleek, modern, and cat-resistant.It’s a little more expensive than some of the other options in this review.
It’s easy to install, made of high-quality stainless steel, corrosion-resistant, water-resistant, and won’t rust.Cats can still destroy the edges of the roll, but not unfurl it.
The top shelf can hold your cell phone or other small items.Larger rolls of toilet paper won’t fit.
The edges are deburred so you won’t get cuts and injuries.
Best for Aesthetics
yeavs Toilet Paper Holder with Phone Shelf and Waterproof Cover
  • Features a sleek, modern design
  • Cat-resistant, rust-resistant, and easy to install
  • Made of stainless steel
  • Has a top shelf that can double as a cell phone holder
  • Has high-quality finishes such as "deburred" edges
Check Amazon

3. Most Practical: YOHOM Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holder With Shelf and Drawer

We love the YOHOM Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holder With Shelf and Drawer because of its attractive extra features. First, of course, is that it keeps your toilet paper away from your pesky cat. You’ll love that it also comes with a shelf and drawer where you can store feminine hygiene products.

This holder is completed enclosed, which makes it waterproof and dustproof too. It comes with a wall holder and doesn’t leave behind any residue. You are even given a backup sticker in case of moves. You should, however, avoid installing this on flaky walls like wallpaper, lime walls, and painted walls.

Are you wondering how this is inexpensive despite all the features it has? Well, this toilet paper holder is made of plastic which is why the price is still affordable. The compact and modern design of this holder makes it another added plus to your space.

Some reviewers said that standard toilet paper rolls won’t fit.

Pros and Cons of the YOHOM Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holder With Shelf and Drawer

ProsCons
This cat-proof toilet paper holder has a shelf and a drawer to store feminine hygiene products.You should avoid installing this holder on flaky walls like wallpaper, lime walls, and painted walls.
It’s completely enclosed, so it’s waterproof and dustproof.Some reviewers said that standard toilet paper rolls won’t fit.
This compact and modern design is made of plastic, which is why it’s so affordable.
Most Practical
YOHOM Wall-Mounted Toilet Paper Roll Holder with Shelf and Drawer
  • Features a shelf and a drawer to store feminine hygiene products
  • Waterproof, cat-proof, and dust-proof
  • Constructed of plastic
  • Compact, modern design
  • Includes a backup adhesive sticker in case you choose to move the holder
Check Amazon

4. Best Premium: JunSun Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holder Stainless Steel Brushed Nickel

Last, but not least, we have the JunSun Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holder Stainless Steel Brushed Nickel. It is among the most popular holders because it looks wonderful and effectively keeps cats out. They can’t even get a paw in. You’ll also love the elegant design of this holder.

The best feature of this holder for us is that the sides are acrylic. This means that you can see how much paper you have left. You’ll also love that this holder has a nickel finish that prevents daily scratches, leaving it looking amazing for a long time.

The JunSun Toilet Paper Holder has an almost enclosed design, making it effectively waterproof. Its body is made from high-quality stainless steel, so this holder is rust-proof. No wonder, so many reviewers love this holder. 

One reviewer summed up an issue that seems to be common among all of these cat-proof toilet paper holders: “It does what I bought it to do, keeps the cat from tearing up the toilet paper. It does not hold a Cottonelle jumbo roll, we have to set the roll on the back of the toilet for a few days until it is small enough to fit the dispenser.”

Pros and Cons of the JunSun Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holder Stainless Steel Brushed Nickel

ProsCons
The sides are acrylic so you can see how much paper you have left.It won’t accommodate a full-sized roll of toilet paper.
The holder has an attractive nickel finish that prevents scratches.
The holder is almost completely enclosed, so it’s effectively waterproof.
The body is made of stainless steel, so it’s rust-proof.
Best Premium
JunSun Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holder Stainless Steel Brushed Nickel
  • The elegant design effectively keeps cats out
  • The acrylic sides allow you to see how much toilet paper you have left
  • Nickel finish on stainless steel prevents scratches
  • Virtually waterproof
  • Rustproof
Check Amazon

Choosing the Best Cat Proof Toilet Paper Holders What to Look For

Now that you’re ready to stop picking up toilet paper strips, it’s important to know what to look for. These are some of the factors we considered when looking for the best cat-proof toilet paper holders.

Ease of Use

While your holder must keep your cat out, it shouldn’t do the same to you. Sometimes, these holders take their jobs too seriously and might make it hard for you to insert and use your tissue.

Aesthetics

Finding a modern design that fits your vision could be hard if you care about the aesthetic. Luckily, we’ve included some great options that you can choose from.

Durability

If your cat often goes for your tissue, there is a chance they’ll try out the box a couple of times before they get the idea. A good cat-proof toilet paper holder should be able to withstand this onslaught.

Ease of Installation

Your toilet paper holder will either need to be drilled into the wall or stuck with adhesive. Please note that using adhesives is not a guarantee that it will be  

Price

It is always better to look at the benefits than the cost when it comes to good products. You can get a great toilet paper holder for a low price to help you keep a low budget.

The Different Types of Cat Proof Toilet Paper Holders: Pros and Cons Compared

Cat proof toilet paper holders are available in two types: completely enclosed and flap-style. Here are the pros and cons of both designs to help you better decide which is best for your household.

Completely Enclosed

ProsCons
Keeps your cat out completely.With some designs, it can be hard to get the tissue out yourself.
Is waterproof and protects your roll. 
Not more expensive than regular paper holder. 

Flap-Style

ProsCons
Can keep cats away from tissue rollCannot prevent spills.
Easy to access for tissue.A brilliant cat might still learn to open the flap.
On the inexpensive side 

The 4 Best Cat-Proof Toilet Paper Holders FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

How do you keep cats off the toilet paper?

Get a cat proof toilet paper holder. We’ve included some of the best and most affordable designs in this review to help make your decision easier.

Why does my cat destroy toilet paper?

Cats either destroy toilet paper because it is fun, or they are practicing hunting skills. Your cat could also be having gum pain and using the tissue as something to gnaw on.

How do you keep toilet paper from falling off the holder?

Make sure you read the instructions before installing your paper holder. After you install it, keep the instructions for future reference.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us? Contact the AZ Animals editorial team.