The Best Blue Buffalo Wet Cat Food: What You Need to Know

Pet trends are sweeping social media, from adorable Instagram pictures to amusing Tiktok videos. Cats and other common pets are clearly ruling the internet, thanks to the rise of pet influencers.

This has also made it easier for pet owners to share pictures, product recommendations, and general pet care tips. As a result, they have more options than ever before, particularly when it comes to the nutritional needs of their felines and furry friends.

Finding the best, wet cat food can be a herculean task. “Should I use products that are grain-free?” “Is wet food even suitable for my cat?” “What about organic food?” These and other questions frequently occupy cat parents’ minds, especially those who are new to cat parenting.

Wet cat food is typically packaged in a can or foil packet. These recipes often include the essential proteins, fats, and micronutrients that your snuggle bug needs to stay frisky.

The primary benefit of wet cat food is hydration. Because it has higher water content than dry, it may be particularly beneficial to cats that have kidney disease, diabetes, or lower urinary tract disease. It is also more flavorful than dry food, so it may entice finicky eaters to consume enough calories and nutrients.

The biggest downside to wet food is that it doesn’t remove plaque and tartar when chewed like dry food does.

From pâtés to minced morsels, cat parents have limitless wet food options to choose from. Making the right choice from a sea of products lined up in digital and physical stores can be difficult. That’s why we’ve compiled a list of the best Blue Buffalo wet cat food ranked by quality, price, and customer reviews. 

A-Z-Animals Top Picks for Blue Buffalo Wet Cat Food

#1 Best Overall: Blue Buffalo Wilderness Turkey Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Turkey Grain-Free Canned Cat Food is our top pick for wet food for your cat. This pâté-style canned food is packed with real turkey and is irresistible to most cats. With turkey, turkey broth, and turkey liver as its three main ingredients, you can rest assured that your fluff ball is getting the protein it needs to maintain lean muscle and that it will be well hydrated, too. Aside from real turkey, this wet cat food contains fruits and vegetables that are rich in antioxidants to help boost their immunity.

This recipe is suitable for all breeds and sizes of adult cats. It’s free from gluten, chicken by-product meals, soy, corn, and other artificial preservatives. A 3-oz. can feeds cats weighing 6 to 8 lb. (2 cans per day) while a 5.5-oz. can feed cats that weigh up to 6 to 8 lb. (1 can per day).

One reviewer tried this product for her two cats who rarely like the same food and she was pleasantly surprised that this was an exception. In her words, “My boys love it. Finding something they both enjoy isn’t always easy, but they chow this down super fast.”

Most reviews for this product were positive, but a few pet parents reported that their cats didn’t like it.

Pros and Cons of Blue Buffalo Wilderness Turkey Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

Best Overall

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Turkey Cat food

• Contains real turkey
• Added fruits and vegetables
• Suitable for all breed sizes of adult cats
• No gluten or other artificial preservatives

Check Chewy Check Amazon

2. Best For Kittens: Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Chicken Entrée for Kittens

If you’re looking for the “purrfect” wet food for your kitty, Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Chicken Entrée for Kittens can be your go-to. This recipe contains essential vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients in the specific quantities your kitten needs to develop properly. You won’t have to worry about optimal bone and tooth development or muscle growth when you feed this protein-rich chicken pâté to your baby cat.

This wet food is an excellent choice for a kitten’s first food because it promotes natural skin and coat health, cognitive development, and a healthy weight.

A reviewer with a picky Bengal kitten said that it was a relief for him to see his kitty eat this food without making a fuss. 

A couple of reviewers said that this food was “mushy.”

Pros and Cons of Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Chicken Entrée for Kittens

Best For Kittens

Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Chicken Entrée Kitten Pate

• Contains essential vitamins and minerals
• Good for muscular growth
• Promotes natural skin and coat health
• High moisture content

Check Chewy Check Amazon

3. Best Grain-Free Option: Blue Buffalo Wilderness Pate Variety Pack

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Pate Variety Pack is best for adult or senior cats that require additional nutritional elements to stay healthy. It’s a protein-packed, delicious wheat-free product that comes in a variety of recipes, including duck pâté, salmon pâte, turkey pâte, and chicken pâté. If you’re just starting to introduce wet food into your cat’s diet, this variety pack will help you determine which flavor is best for your cat.

This wheat-free food is also free from chicken (or poultry) by-product meals, corn, soy, and artificial flavors and preservatives. Each flavor starts with high-quality meat and healthy carbohydrates from fruits and vegetables and is enhanced with vitamins and minerals.

One reviewer fed the duck pâte to an 8-year-old Siamese cat to control excessive shedding. She combined it with dry cat food and fed it to her once a week. It’s safe to say that the product worked because now her cat has soft, shiny fur, and shedding has been dramatically reduced.

Some reviewers said that this food was too expensive, while a few reported that their cats won’t eat it.

Pros and Cons of Blue Wilderness High Protein Grain-Free Wet Cat Food

Best High Protein

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Pate Variety Pack

• High-quality protein is essential for cats
• Includes flavors like chicken, salmon, and duck
• Added amino acids
• No by-product meals, soy, corn, or wheat

Check Chewy Check Amazon

4. Best For Cats with Dry, Irritated Skin and/or Sensitive Stomach: Basics Skin and Stomach Care Indoor Cat Duck and Potato Entrée

If your cat has dry, irritated skin and/or a sensitive stomach, consider Basics Skin and Stomach Care Indoor Cat Duck and Potato Entrée. This limited-ingredient product is suitable for cats with sensitive stomachs. To aid digestion, it contains duck as the sole animal protein source as well as potatoes and pumpkins. This wet cat food is tailored to the needs of indoor cats, and its omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids promote skin and coat health.

One reviewer said: “My elderly Maine Coon has stopped vomiting, thanks to this diet. His stomach is now sensitive, therefore this was a fantastic solution. Our chubby cat has also lost a couple of ounces in his middle thanks to the limited ingredient list.”

Some reviewers said that this cat food was too expensive, while a few reported that their cats wouldn’t eat it.

Pros and Cons of Basics Skin and Stomach Care Indoor Cat Duck and Potato Entrée

Best For Cats with Dry, Irritated Skin and/or Sensitive Stomach

Blue Buffalo Basics Skin & Stomach Care

• Limited-ingredient product
• Contains only one animal protein source
• Best for indoor cats
• Smooth paté texture

Check Chewy Check Amazon

5. Best for Weaning Kittens: Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Wet Cat Food for Kittens

DHA-formulated Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Wet Cat Food for Kittens, contains real chicken as well as fruits and vegetables to give your kitten a good nutritional start in life. DHA is an essential fatty acid found in mothers’ milk that aids in the cognitive development of kittens.

Some of the other healthy ingredients in this kitten food include carrots, flaxseeds, sweet potatoes, cranberries, and chicken liver.

Aside from its nutritious ingredients, this wet cat food has a smooth pâté texture that your feline companion will enjoy. Blue Buffalo’s Freedom Grain-Free makes weaning kittens onto solids a walk in the park.

Following a vet’s recommendation, a reviewer decided to buy this product for her newly adopted kitten. She said, “My kitten has already gone through about five cans and continues to devour the food every time I feed it to her. She is perfectly healthy and her coat looks great. I plan to continue using this until she is a year old.”

Some reviewers said that their cats became ill after eating this food, including vomiting and allergic reactions.

Pros and Cons of Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Wet Cat Food for Kittens

Best For Weaning Kittens

Blue Buffalo Freedom Indoor Kitten Chicken Recipe

• A DHA-formulated product
• Smooth paté texture
• Grain-free
• Contains healthy vegetables

Check Chewy Check Amazon

6. Best for Weight Management: Blue True Solutions Fit and Healthy Weight Control Formula Adult Cat Wet Food

Blue True Solutions Fit and Healthy Weight Control Formula Adult Cat Wet Food is formulated with L-carnitine to help your adult cat reach and maintain a healthy weight. It’s also enriched with fiber to help your cat feel full longer.

This wheat-free wet cat food starts with high-quality chicken and includes wholesome fruits and veggies to help control your adult cat’s weight naturally. It’s enriched with vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients. And it’s free from the ingredients you don’t want to feed your cat, including chicken (or poultry) by-product meals, corn, soy, artificial flavors or preservatives.

This product was suggested to a reviewer who tried it for his Persian cat. He tried a can and his cat loved everything about the food. She has also been losing weight.

Some reviewers reported that their cats don’t like this food.

Pros and Cons of Blue True Solutions Fit and Healthy Weight Control Formula Adult Cat Wet Food

Best Wet Food

Blue Buffalo True Solutions Canned Wet

• Wet food
• Veterinarian-recommended formula
• Chicken and poultry byproduct-free
• Enriched with vitamins, minerals and nutrients
• L-Carnitine helps your cat maintain its ideal weight

Check Chewy Check Amazon

Choosing The Best: What To Look For

When you’re shopping for cat food, you should keep the following criterion in mind: ingredients, AAFCO compliance, your cat’s flavor preferences, and price.

Ingredients

This is a major factor to consider when choosing wet food for your cat. Does it have grains? What about its protein content? Answering some of these questions will help you choose food based on the unique needs of your cat. Cats are naturally meat-eaters, so protein is an important ingredient to look for on a product’s label.

AAFCO Compliance

AAFCO stands for the American Association of Feed Control Officials. The phrase “complete and balanced” should be on the label, and it should say that the food meets or exceeds the AAFCO’s nutritional requirements. 

Your Cat’s Flavor Preferences

Cats are well known for being finicky. Your cat may turn up its adorable nose at gourmet foods that other cats devour on sight. Or, even more frustrating, it may refuse to eat food that it loved as recently as yesterday. That’s why it makes sense to only buy flavors that your cat likes. Otherwise, you may end up with a case of pricey food that Fluffy will never eat.

Price

High-quality cat food is more expensive than bargain brands for a reason. It simply costs more to manufacturer premium cat food that includes real meat, fruits, veggies, and supplements. Bargain brands include animal by-products and other low-cost ingredients that are widely known as “fillers.”

While you will pay more for high-quality cat food, we think it’s worth it. Your feline friend will likely be healthier and live a longer, happier life.

Up Next…

Check out a few of our other cat food articles here.

• Best Cat Food For Diabetic Cats – See the list of safe food options for your diabetic cat.
• Best High Protein Food – Make sure your pet is getting all of its protein with these foods.
• Best High-Fiber Cat Food – Cat owners are loving these foods that keep their pet’s gut healthy.