Fleas may be small, but they’re downright terrible. At the very least, they can cause your dog’s skin to get irritated. But if left unchecked, these parasites can transmit diseases to your dogs such as plague, tapeworms, and typhus. Fleas can even infest your home. While they can’t live on human skin, they can still bite you, which can cause itching.
Of course, not all flea collars and tags are created equal. There are different types available. Some flea collars are designed for prevention (by repelling fleas) while others are for treating an existing problem (kills fleas). With the latter, there are also different types. Some kill only adult fleas while there are flea collars that target eggs and larvae. You’ll find collars and tags that contain natural ingredients (hypoallergenic) and ones that use chemical insecticides for fast-acting relief. There are even some that are waterproof.
Obviously, there are all sorts of flea collars and tags for you to choose from. And the best one for your pet will depend on several different factors including function, size (small or large dog), ingredients, and longevity. To help you make sure that you make the right choice for your canine, we decided to test the ones we could find and let you know the results.
#1 Best Overall Flea Collar (Verified Review): Seresto Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs
- Provides 8-months of continuous flea and tick prevention
- Seresto flea and tick collar for large dogs works through contact, so fleas and ticks do not have to bite your dog to die
- Veterinarian-recommended flea and tick prevention for dogs in a convenient, odorless and non-greasy collar; No need for messy monthly treatments
- Starts to repel and kill fleas within 24 hours of initial application
- Flea and tick collar for large dogs also helps treat and control sarcoptic mange and kills lice
When it comes to the prevention and treatment of fleas and ticks, the flea collar that is recommended by most vets is Seresto. Its two main ingredients are imidacloprid and flumethrin which, as this study shows, is incredibly effective in taking out fleas and ticks. Of course, we couldn’t just take their word for it. We had to do some testing on our own.
Based on our experience, this flea collar had no odor at all which makes it ideal for sensitive noses (and we’re not just talking about dogs here). Plus, it comes with a non-greasy formula. More importantly, our happy volunteer (one of the doggos of our staff) didn’t catch any fleas or ticks after we left him romping around outdoors.
Of course, flea prevention is not the only thing this collar is good for. According to Bayer, it should be able to kill fleas – both adults and eggs – within 24-48 hours after application. Using a different dog, we did find that it does reduce the number of fleas we could find on his fur within their promised time frame. And none of our volunteers had allergic reactions to the collar while wearing it for several days. So, fast-acting and effective? Check!
Some other things that you need to know about the Seresto collar. It features reflector chips for visibility at night. It comes with a quick safety release mechanism in case the collar gets caught on something. Plus, the collar can also treat sarcoptic mange.
As much as we loved this product, we do have to be honest about some of the drawbacks of using the Seresto collar. First is the cost. Compared to other collars in the market, this one is priced at over $50. It definitely does not come cheap (though well worth the price). The second disadvantage is that this flea collar is only water-resistant, not waterproof. Unless you only let your dog bathe or get wet once a month, the effectiveness of this collar against fleas goes down from 8 months to 5.
Overall, the Seresto collar receives a huge thumbs up from us. Just keep in mind that Bayer offers two types of Seresto collars. One is for large dogs weighing 18 lbs and over. The other is for small dogs weighing less than 18 lbs. Make sure to read the label before buying.
Click here to check out Seresto Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs
#2 Best Natural Flea Collar (Verified Review): SOBAKEN Flea and Tick Prevention for Dogs
- ✅8 MONTH PROTECTION – Flea and Tick Сollar for dogs protect your pet or puppy from flea and ticks 24h/7 days a week during 8 MONTHS.
- ✅MORE POWERFUL – New formula. More effective flea and tick prevention for dogs than other collars and still hypoallergenic for you and your pet.
- ✅AGE FOR USING – You can start use Collar from 3 month age of your pet. You can use our collar for SMALL, MEDIUM and LARGE dogs
- ✅WATERPROOF – Continues to be 100% effective after bathing and playing in the rain.
- ✅CHARITY – with every sold collar we donate 3$ to Organizations that are engaged in saving animals. Help us to give them hope!
Not everyone is comfortable in having their beloved dogs wear a collar filled with insecticides. So, for those who want something more natural, we recommend the Sobaken Flea and Tick Collar. Unlike the Seresto collar, this one contains a non-toxic, hypoallergenic formula – specifically spearmint, citronella, and clove. You can’t get any more natural than essential oils.
Now, we must admit that we did find the odor of the collar to be a bit on the strong side. And one of our canine volunteers definitely wasn’t a fan of the smell. But if you air it out a bit, as recommended by some users, it can become tolerable.
As we’ve mentioned, this flea collar features hypoallergenic ingredients which means they’re ideal for pets that have sensitive skin and experience allergic reactions to the usual flea collars in the market. In our testing, we didn’t find any rashes or redness on our dog’s skin.
Like the Seresto collar, this Sobaken flea collar is great at repelling fleas and ticks. But it can also be used to repel chewing lice, mosquitoes, and flea larvae. In addition, it provides your dog with protection for 8 whole months. And, unlike the Seresto collar, this one is waterproof.
The collar comes in only one size, but it can be adjusted to fit both large dogs and small ones as well as any size in between. You can start using this collar as soon as your pup is 3 months of age.
Take note that this flea collar is great at prevention. But in our testing, it doesn’t seem to be as fast-acting as our pick for best overall flea collar. Of course, if you want something 100% natural and a little more affordable, then the Sobaken flea collar is the right one for your pet.
Click here to check out SOBAKEN Flea and Tick Prevention for Dogs
#3 Best Waterproof Flea Collar (Verified Review): Rolf Club 3D Flea Collar for Dogs
- ✅New German Formula: More than 6 months of Best Protection-New German Technology gives you effective flea and tick prevention for dogs for 6 month!
- ✅3D Protection for your pet – effective against Fleas - larvae - Ticks and Mosquitoes. This flea collar for dogs was designed to be HELPFUL either for small medium size or large pets.
- ✅Quick effect– Rolf 3D Dog flea collar kills fleas within the first 24-48 hours after the start of use. Its main aim is to provide your pet with proper flea tick treatment & this flea tick collar does it well.
- ✅Knock down effect – Tested by the best vets: new German formula was specially used in the best flea collar and helps to achieve the best results.
- ✅Adjustable Flea Collar - Suitable for different sizes dogs
If your pup is actually part fish, then you’ll need a flea collar that can handle getting immersed in water a lot. And while we do love Seresto’s flea collar, it isn’t known for remaining effective when frequently exposed to water. In fact, exposure to water shortens the effectiveness of the collar from 8 months down to 5 months. Naturally, you’ll want something that’s waterproof and not water-resistant. And based on our tests, the most effective flea collar that your dog can take with him swimming is the Rolf Club 3D Flea Collar.
First off, we have to admit that the duration of protection provided by this collar is much shorter than our two other picks. The Rolf Club 3D Flea Collar is only good for 6 months. That being said, it is a solid choice if you want an effective treatment and prevention for fleas, ticks, mosquitoes, and larvae. During our testing, we did find evidence that it can kill fleas and ticks within 48 hours of wearing the collar. There was no smell and residue.
So, what about the ingredients? Unlike the Seresto collar, this one uses Fipronil, D-cifenotrin, and Pyriproxifen. According to the EPA, all of these chemicals may be potent insecticides but are generally not going to harm your pets or your loved ones. However, because of the strength of these chemicals, the flea collar is not recommended for use on puppies younger than 12 weeks. Also, make sure that your dog does not have an allergic reaction to the insecticides by checking his skin from time to time. Our lovely lab didn’t seem to mind wearing the collar and her skin was a-ok upon checking. We did appreciate that the collar comes in three sizes and all of the sizes are adjustable. Plus, we found the collar easy to put on.
You’ll note that this flea collar is more than half the price of the Seresto collar, making it a lot more affordable than any of our picks. But while it was effective for our labrador, there have been reports that it didn’t completely eliminate ticks from some pets. Overall, this flea collar gets our vote as the best option for dogs who love to get wet and pet parents who have a limited budget.
Click here to check out Rolf Club 3D Flea Collar for Dogs
Last update on 2021-10-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
The Top Picks for Best Flea Collar: Reviewed for 2021 FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)
What is the most effective flea collar for dogs?
The most effective flea collar is one that not only treats fleas but also prevents an infestation. Moreover, it should also be able to target fleas in various life stages – adult, larvae, and eggs. Another requirement for a flea collar to be effective is how it provides protection to all areas of your dog’s body. The collar should be able to distribute the active ingredients throughout your dog’s body, not just around the neck and shoulders.
Of course, having the right ingredients is also important. The chemicals used must be fast-acting. In addition, they should also be of zero to low toxicity to your pet as well as humans. Based on one scientific study, the combination of imidacloprid and flumethrin are not only effective insecticides for fleas but also good for killing ticks. Not only that, these insecticides are able to kill fleas and ticks within 24 to 48 hours. Moreover, these ingredients are very low in toxicity to humans, especially when exposed via skin transfer. This is an important consideration since you and your loved ones will most likely be petting your dog throughout flea season and beyond.
Aside from containing effective ingredients, the best flea collar should last a good long while – longer than flea season. In fact, the longer the protection the better. In addition, the most effective flea collar should be easy to apply and not greasy. You don’t want to see traces of the insecticide greasing up the various surfaces in your home. As you can see, all the requirements we set for the best flea collar in the market can be met by the Seresto Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs.
What flea collar do vets recommend?
Before you purchase a flea collar for your dog, it’s important that you first talk to your vet. The vet will know what treatment and prevention methods are best for your dog based on the risk of your pet getting fleas and his/her health.
That being said, a majority of veterinarians do recommend using the Seresto collar. This is because it’s an effective alternative to topical treatments. Instead of needing to reapply the treatment monthly, pet parents can rest easy for that their doggos are protected for at least 8 months. It’s a set-it-and-forget-it solution.
Important note: the EPA is currently investigating a report of a possible link between the Seresto flea collar to almost 1,700 pet deaths that occurred between 2012 and June 2020. However, it has been noted that the EPA has yet to ban or recall the use of the product. Moreover, veterinarians still recommend the Seresto collar because it’s both safe and effective.
Do flea collars for dogs really work?
Flea collars are effective in both the prevention and treatment of fleas and ticks. There are two ways that these products work. Older style flea collars emit a gas that is toxic to fleas, killing them when they get into contact. However, this limited the effectiveness of the product because it could only offer protection to areas of the body in close proximity to the collar (i.e. the neck). Modern flea collars, on the other hand, typically contain ingredients that are continuously released from the collar. These ingredients are then spread throughout the dog’s body via the natural oils in your dog’s fur and skin. Depending on the active ingredient used, the flea collar will either repel fleas or kill them on contact.
It is important to note, however, that in cases of severe infestation, it might be best to use a flea collar along with another type of treatment. Please consult with your vet first before using a collar or combining it with a different type of flea treatment.