19 Ideal Pets for Multi-Pet Households

If you’re the type who can’t stop at just one animal…whether they be furry, scaly, or feathery, you’re in the right place. Some animals are just naturally better at sharing space and getting along with others. So, we put a list together and we’re going to do a rundown of 19 pets that tend to thrive in multi-pet households.

What kind of a piece would this be if we didn’t put the famous golden retrievers here! Golden Retrievers are famously easygoing and social pets. They’re great with other dogs, cats, and even smaller animals. Their gentle nature makes them perfect for multi-pet homes where the peaceful vibes do matter. Just give them attention, and they’ll happily share the spotlight with other pets.

Perhaps you have a dog already and are considering a cat, but are unsure. Well, not every cat is a diva. Breeds like Ragdolls and Maine Coons tend to be chill and even playful with dogs. If you want a cat that won't hide from the pack, these sociable kitties are often up for the challenge.

Budgerigars, or more commonly referred to as budgies, are tiny parrots with very outgoing personalities. They do well with other flocks of birds and can peacefully coexist with calm dogs or cats. Just make sure their cage is secure, and they’ll chirp happily in a bustling household without much fuss.

Ferrets are naturally curious and playful animals, and they often enjoy the company of both humans and other pets. They can get along with cats and dogs. Just make sure that the introductions are slow and supervised. You can definitely expect a lot of zoomies!

Not all bunnies are timid. Certain breeds, like the Mini Rex or Holland Lop, are actually pretty laid-back and can adjust to other animals in the house. With proper intros, they can coexist for a very long time with gentle cats and dogs. As long as they are in a calm, respectful environment.

Labs are famously friendly and adaptable to any type of household. They typically get along with just about everyone, from humans, other dogs, cats, and even birds. Their patient attitude and love for companionship make them a top choice for pet-packed households.

Guinea pigs are herd animals by nature, so they do best with others. They’re also low-key enough to live peacefully in homes with dogs or cats, as long as everyone respects their space. So, let this little pet bring you joy, squeaking and rolling around with your cat or dog in tow.

As you might guess, yes, boxers bring energy.  However, they also bring a big heart to multi-pet homes. They’re especially good with other dogs and can learn to live peacefully with cats if raised together. Their playful nature helps them bond easily, and they rarely turn down a chance to make friends.

Turtles don’t need much socialization, so they could easily be that quiet roommate you’ve always wanted. They do well in peaceful multi-pet homes where other animals won’t mess with their tank. Dogs and cats can coexist peacefully with turtles, especially if you keep their habitat separate and stress-free. 

Poodles are surprisingly good at reading the room. They’re intelligent and often thrive in homes with other dogs or various other animals. Their trainability helps keep things harmonious, and they usually bond well with both people and pets if raised in a safe and friendly setting.

Cockatiels love companionship and can do well in multi-pet homes. Just please make sure that their space is respected. These birds love to chat and sing. And yes, while they’re delicate, they often enjoy watching the action around them. Especially from the safety of their perch away from paws.

This breed thrives on companionship, not competition. So, as you can imagine this would make a perfect pet for your multi-pet household. Cavaliers are gentle and super adaptable. They’re often fine with cats, other dogs, and even smaller critters. As long as they get love, they’re content with sharing.

If you’ve got a yard, chickens can actually coexist with cats and dogs surprisingly well. They stick to their flock and mind their business. And of course, they provide fresh eggs as a bonus. Just be sure to keep them safe from overly curious or predatory pets in the area.

Goats are more than just grass cutters, keeping your grass low. They’re social and often thrive when living with other animals. They do especially well in homes with dogs, chickens, and of course, other livestock. Just make sure they’ve got space to roam and climb, and we promise they’ll be everyone’s buddy.

Now, a Tegus may look like a little dinosaurs and seem intimidating. But they’re often friendly and calm with the right care. Now, they’re not cuddly, but they can coexist peacefully in homes with other pets. Just keep their tank safe, that’s all they ask.

Collies are intelligent and easy-to-train breeds. They’re herding dogs, so they often do well managing and watching over other pets. Their nurturing instincts and gentle temperament make them a natural fit for families with a mix of animals. Let them be the mother of the household.

Hamsters don’t play well with their own kind, but they’re fine in homes with larger pets. Just make sure you keep interactions supervised. We don’t want things getting out of hand due to how small hamsters are. Their enclosures should be secure, but they’re independent enough not to be phased by the presence of dogs or cats. 

Sometimes the best multi-pet companions are mixed breeds. Shelter dogs often come with a known history of behavior and tolerance, so you can choose one who already plays well with others. And a calm, well-mannered mutt can be a true friendly addition in mixed homes.

Now, the easiest combo of all? A dog and a cat raised together from kittenhood and puppyhood. With this type of early bonding and respectful training, they often form lifelong friendships. They learn each other’s languages and boundaries early on. This type of foundation creates a low-drama home for everyone.