The Most Expensive Lakes in Pennsylvania to Buy a Second Home

Written by Em Casalena
Updated: August 24, 2023
Share on:

Advertisement


Are you interested in buying a second home in Pennsylvania? Perhaps you’re looking for something with gorgeous lakefront views? Depending on your budget, you have quite a few options. However, there are some expensive lakes in Pennsylvania that are known for being the lap of luxury for homeowners.

Infographic for the Most Expensive Lake to buy a 2nd home in Pennsylvania
The Poconos provide the site for most of these picturesque lakes and their fabulous houses.

Let’s take a look at some interesting details!

1. Lake Wynonah

Pennsylvania‘s gorgeous Lake Wynonah reservoir is tucked away among the state’s undulating hills. This man-made lake is in a gated neighborhood in Schuylkill County. It offers an enchanting refuge for residents seeking the peace and beauty of the natural world. Lake Wynonah spans more than 550 acres and is a refuge for both water sports enthusiasts and nature lovers.

Lake Wynonah’s history began in the mid-1960s when the region was converted into a paradise for relaxation. The lake itself was originally built as a water storage facility. It has now developed into a prestigious neighborhood noted for its opulent residences and tranquil settings. The Little Schuylkill River was dammed to create the lake. Now, it is a crystal-clear body of water that reflects the beauty of its surroundings.

For a number of reasons, wealthy homeowners are drawn to Lake Wynonah. To start, the region provides a sense of solitude and privacy. This enables inhabitants to get away from the stresses of daily life. Elegant homes with wonderful views of the lake and the surrounding greenery border the lake’s extensive shoreline. These luxurious residences offer a sanctuary for unwinding and a location to make priceless memories with family and friends.

Just as well, Lake Wynonah provides a wide range of facilities to improve the quality of life for its people. The neighborhood has a clubhouse, tennis courts, swimming pools, and other recreational amenities. A thriving community of outdoor enthusiasts is fostered by the lake’s popular boating, fishing, and water sports. Houses for sale around this lake are often over $600,000.

The scenic beauty of the Schuylkill River Trail, in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania.

Lake Wynona is on the Little Schuylkill River, a tributary of the Schuylkill River.

©Scenic Corner/Shutterstock.com

2. Lake Wallenpaupack

The mesmerizing location of Lake Wallenpaupack in Pennsylvania’s picturesque Pocono Mountains is well known for its natural beauty and recreational activities. This man-made lake, which spans more than 5,700 acres, is a beloved getaway that has won the hearts of both residents and tourists.

The Pennsylvania Power and Light Company built a hydroelectric dam on the Wallenpaupack Creek in the mid-20th century, which is when Lake Wallenpaupack first appeared. The lake was finished in 1926 and was given its name from the Lenape Native American term for “The Stream of Swift and Slow Water.” Today, it provides water to nearby villages and acts as a crucial reservoir for producing energy.

Lake Wallenpaupack’s alluring beauty and a wide variety of leisure opportunities attract affluent residents from around the country. The lake has a shoreline that extends over 50 miles and is lined with opulent homes that offer breathtaking views and easy access to the water. Because of the lakefront’s expansive views and accessibility to boating, fishing, swimming, and other water sports, waterfront houses are in high demand and often listed at over $1 million.

Along with its natural beauty, Lake Wallenpaupack is bordered by quaint villages and a lively neighborhood. The region offers a wealth of amenities, including marinas, dining establishments, hiking trails, golf courses, and cultural attractions, making it a desirable location for anyone looking for a peaceful yet active lifestyle. This is truly one of the most beautiful and expensive lakes in Pennsylvania.

Lake Wallenpaupack

Lake Wallenpaupack (pictured) is known for its small, quant villages and neighborhoods.

©iStock.com/Frank DeBonis

3. Lake Naomi

In the picturesque Pocono Pines region of Pennsylvania, Lake Naomi is a sought-after vacation spot renowned for its unspoiled beauty and opulent lifestyle. Homeowners looking for a luxurious and idyllic spot for their second home can find an exquisite getaway in this private lake neighborhood, which is spread across over 277 acres.

The creation of Lake Naomi as a top holiday destination may be traced back to the middle of the 1960s. The artificial lake is a serene body of water that reflects the beauty of its surroundings. Lake Naomi has become a prominent neighborhood throughout the years, drawing affluent people who cherish exclusivity, solitude, and a great respect for nature.

Due to its first-rate amenities and plenty of recreational options, Lake Naomi real estate tends to attract wealthy buyers. A gorgeous clubhouse, an outdoor Olympic-sized pool, tennis courts, and a private beach are just a few of the community’s luxury features. Additionally, nearby residents have access to recreational opportunities including boating, fishing, kayaking, hiking, and golfing.

Additionally, the elegant homes and well-considered architecture of Lake Naomi are made to enhance the area’s natural beauty. Elegant houses with contemporary designs, open floor plans, and high-end finishes can be found in the neighborhood around Lake Naomi. Numerous villas provide stunning views of the lake, luxuriant trees, and the neighboring mountains, fostering a quiet and serene atmosphere. Many of the lakefront homes on Lake Naomi are listed at over $1.5 million.

Lake Naomi

Lake Naomi is a reservoir in the scenic Pocono Pines region of Pennsylvania.

©Mateo Prieto/Shutterstock.com

4. Lake Harmony

Homeowners seeking outdoor activity and natural beauty have long appreciated Lake Harmony, a mesmerizing lake situated in Pennsylvania’s picturesque Pocono Mountains. This charming glacial lake is a well-liked getaway because of its breathtaking surroundings and lively neighborhood vibe.

Lake Harmony has a long history since Native American tribes used to live there years ago. It became a tourist destination throughout time, drawing travelers with its beautiful surroundings and serene waters. It still enchants homeowners today with its beauty; especially wealthy homeowners.

For a number of reasons, affluent homeowners are drawn to Lake Harmony. To start, the lake provides a sense of remoteness and calmness that allows locals to get away from the rush of daily life. For those wanting a quiet vacation, the lakeside villas in the region offer an exclusive and peaceful atmosphere.

Lake Harmony is very well known for its year-round leisure opportunities. There are several outdoor activities available, such as boating, fishing, and swimming in the summer and skiing, snowboarding, and ice fishing in the winter. Numerous ski resorts, golf courses, hiking trails, and water parks can be found in the vicinity, offering a variety of leisure activities.

Just as well, Lake Harmony’s attraction is increased by how close it is to important cities like Philadelphia and New York City. For wealthy homeowners, it is quite convenient to have access to a tranquil lakeside hideaway within a very short commute. Homes along this lake tend to be listed at over $2 million dollars, making it one of the most expensive lakes in Pennsylvania.

Lake Harmony

Lake Harmony (pictured) is a testament to Pennsylvania’s natural beauty.

©Jeremy Tyree/Shutterstock.com

5. Lake Erie

It’s worth noting that Lake Erie borders many states, not just Pennsylvania. That being said, Lake Erie offers a breathtaking beachfront experience and draws affluent homeowners to its beaches. The Great Lake of Erie, which separates the United States from Canada, has the fourth-largest surface area of all the Great Lakes. Those looking for an opulent lakefront lifestyle can find a compelling getaway along Pennsylvania’s Lake Erie beachfront.

Native American tribes like the Erie and Iroquois lived in the area for millennia, giving Lake Erie its long history. As a result of increasing activity brought about by European discovery and colonization, villages and cities gradually grew along the coastline.

For a variety of reasons, affluent homeowners are drawn to Lake Erie. The lake offers tranquility and breathtaking vistas. Properties along the water’s edge offer expansive views of the sparkling seas, which contributes to the peaceful mood. A variety of leisure opportunities are also provided by Lake Erie, drawing wealthy customers who like outdoor sports. Popular local pleasures include boating, fishing, water sports, and beachgoing, which inhabitants may enjoy in a beautiful environment.

Just as well, premium villages and appealing neighborhoods dot the shores of Lake Erie. These communities have opulent residences, waterfront properties, and access to priceless extras like private beaches, marinas, and golf courses. Rich homeowners are drawn to the area because of the ease of the amenities close and the chance to live a posh lakefront lifestyle. Homes along Lake Erie range drastically in price from $200,000 to over $2 million, making it one of the most affordable but also most expensive lakes in Pennsylvania.

Lake Erie

As one of the Great Lakes, Lake Erie has vast expanses of water that border four states and one province.

©iStock.com/becky johnson

These expensive lakes in Pennsylvania are truly the lap of luxury for wealthy homeowners who want to buy a second home somewhere beautiful!

Summary of the 5 Most Expensive Lake in Pennsylvania to Buy a Second Home

NameCostLocation
Lake Wynonah$600,000West of Allentown on Hwy. 183
Lake Wallenpaupack$1M+In the Pocono Mountains near Scranton
Lake Naomi$1.5MPocono Pines region, off I-80 and I-380
Lake Harmony$2M+North of Allentown in the Pocono Mountains
Lake Erie$200,000 – $2M+Far Northwest corner of state

The photo featured at the top of this post is © Doug Lemke/Shutterstock.com


Share on:
About the Author

Em Casalena is a writer at A-Z Animals where their primary focus is on plants, gardening, and sustainability. Em has been writing and researching about plants for nearly a decade and is a proud Southwest Institute of Healing Arts graduate and certified Urban Farming instructor. Em is a resident of Arizona and enjoys learning about eco-conscious living, thrifting at local shops, and caring for their Siamese cat Vladimir.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us? Contact the AZ Animals editorial team.