Best Organic Dog Food: Reviewed for You

Written by Judie Sigdel
Updated: November 16, 2022
©

This post may contain affiliate links to our partners like Chewy, Amazon, and others. Purchasing through these helps us further the A-Z Animals mission to educate about the world's species..

Key Points

  • The #1 Best Overall organic dog food is the Castor & Pollux Organix Dry Dog Food (Chicken and Oatmeal).
  • Not every type of organic food is equal — some are 100% organic certified, while others simply contain natural ingredients.
  • There are many different factors to consider when it comes to choosing the right organic food for your pet — such as wet vs. dry food, age and size of the dog, and any allergies they have.

Our dogs are our family and we only want what is best for them. One way to take care of your pup is by choosing the best food to keep them healthy and strong. Many dog owners are turning to fresh and natural organic dog foods because they don’t contain the questionable ingredients or pesticide residues that are present in some conventional foods.

However, finding the right organic dog food for your canine companion isn’t an easy task. Organic food can be more challenging to find, and pricier on top of that. You also may not be sure which one offers the right formula for your dog. To help make this difficult decision a bit easier for you, we’ve put together a selection of some of the best organic wet and dry foods on the market.

Whether you’re looking for organic food for puppies or for your dog with a sensitive stomach, we’ve got you covered!

  1. Castor & Pollux ORGANIX Organic Dry Dog Food
  2. Castor & Pollux ORGANIX Organic Dry Dog Food

    • Organic dog food made with superfoods

    • Free from artificial ingredients

    • Multiple flavor and sizing options

    • USDA Approved

    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  3. Purina Beyond Organic Wet Dog Food
  4. Purina Beyond Organic Wet Dog Food
    • Beyond Organic non-GMO dog food pate with free-range chicken
    • No prohibited synthetic pesticides or fertilizers
    • Added vitamins and minerals and with no artificial colors, flavors or preservatives
    • No corn, wheat, soy or poultry by-product meal


    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  5. Castor & Pollux Organix Grain-Free Adult Canned Dog Food
  6. Castor & Pollux Organix Grain-Free Adult Canned Dog Food

    •Free-range protein organic wet dog food

    •Multiple flavor variations

    •USDA approved

    •No artificial ingredients

    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  7. Dr. Harvey's Canine Health Miracle Dog Food
  8. Dr. Harvey's Canine Health Miracle Dog Food

    •Human-grade, dehydrated, organic dog food

    •Easy use for healthy, happy dog

    •Improved energy, shiny coat, healthy joints


    Check Amazon

The Top Picks for Organic Dog Food: Ranked for 2022

#1 Best Overall: Castor & Pollux Organix Dry Dog Food (Chicken and Oatmeal)

After careful consideration we selected the Castor & Pollux Organix Dry Dog Food (Chicken and Oatmeal) as the best overall organic dog food.

As a company that complies with the USDA Natural Organic program regulations, Castor & Pollux were reviewed by independent, USDA-accredited experts. This means that their food can be tested for compliance and should provide you with additional peace of mind that the ingredients listed on the bag are a true representation of what is inside.

This food is formulated for adult dogs and is made using organic ingredients. It does not contain any artificial preservatives, flavors, or colors, so you can rest easy knowing your dog is eating a healthy meal. The ingredients include organic chicken, oatmeal, barley, brown rice, and peas. It also includes a blend of fresh superfoods such as organic blueberries, coconut oil, and flaxseed. The grains — such as oatmeal, barley, and brown rice — are designed to aid in digestion, making this a good option for dogs with sensitive stomachs.

Although it is a four-pound bag of chicken and oatmeal flavor food, there is also a larger bag available (18 pounds). Additionally, there is a chicken and sweet potato flavor available in the same two bag sizes.

Although there are a lot of positive things about this food, some users have reported that their pets don’t like it.

Pros and Cons of the Castor & Pollux Organix Dry Dog Food

ProsCons
This food is made using entirely organic ingredients — including chicken, oatmeal, barley, brown rice, peas, blueberries, coconut oil, and flaxseed.Not every dog likes this food.
The grains (oatmeal, barley, and brown rice) are designed to aid digestion.
Castor & Pollux are compliant with USDA Natural Organic program regulations.
This food comes in two bag sizes and two different flavors.
Best Overall
Castor & Pollux ORGANIX Organic Dry Dog Food

• Organic dog food made with superfoods

• Free from artificial ingredients

• Multiple flavor and sizing options

• USDA Approved

Check Chewy Check Amazon

2. Most Affordable: Purina Beyond Organic High Protein Wet Food

If you’re trying to stick to a budget then take a look at the Purina Beyond Organic High Protein Wet Food.

Compared to other similar wet dog foods, this is a more affordable option that will still help you provide your dog with a high-quality meal made with fresh ingredients. The USDA Organic seal on the label tells you that there are no synthetic pesticides or fertilizers in the food that could harm your dog.

The first ingredient in this wet food is organic free-range chicken. Other organic ingredients include chicken broth, chicken liver, and carrots. This food is also formulated with essential vitamins and minerals to keep dogs healthy. These include vitamin E, vitamin D-3, riboflavin, zinc sulfate, and manganese sulfate. It has a guaranteed analysis of containing a minimum of 7% crude protein, a minimum of 6% crude fat, a maximum of 1.5% crude fiber, and a maximum of 80% moisture.

One of the best things about this food is that it is free from fillers, corn, wheat, soy, poultry by-products, artificial colors, artificial flavors, and artificial preservatives. Additionally, this food is sold in a 12-pack with every can weighing 13 ounces, which is great value for money.

However, some pet parents have reported that their dogs don’t like this food, while others have found that it dries out quickly once open — even when suitably stored.

Pros and Cons of the Purina Beyond Organic High Protein Wet Food

ProsCons
This dog food is certified USDA organic.Not every dog likes this food.
This food contains organic ingredients — including chicken broth, chicken liver, and carrotsIt can dry out quickly once open, even when stored correctly.
It is completely free from artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives.
This food is formulated with essential vitamins and minerals to keep dogs healthy.
Most Affordable
Purina Beyond Organic Wet Dog Food
  • Beyond Organic non-GMO dog food pate with free-range chicken
  • No prohibited synthetic pesticides or fertilizers
  • Added vitamins and minerals and with no artificial colors, flavors or preservatives
  • No corn, wheat, soy or poultry by-product meal


Check Chewy Check Amazon

3. Best Canned: Castor & Pollux Organix Grain Free Canned Wet Dog Food

Our selection as the best canned food is the Castor & Pollux Organix Grain Free Canned Wet Dog Food.

This food is available in a variety of flavors and the number one ingredient in each of these wet foods is organic free-range poultry. Each can is specially formulated with nutrient-rich superfoods like coconut flour, flaxseed, and blueberries. This food is USDA organic certified which gives you complete peace of mind about the ingredients that your beloved pet is consuming.

As this wet food doesn’t contain any synthetic fertilizers, chemical pesticides, added growth hormones, antibiotics, or artificial preservatives, you can feel confident that your canine companion is getting the best nutrition to help them stay happy and healthy. If you’re looking for grain-free food, either due to allergies or other purposes, this is a great choice to consider.

Although this food is available in several different flavors, some users have reported that their pets dislike the turkey and vegetable option.

Pros and Cons of the Castor & Pollux Organix Grain Free Canned Wet Dog Food

ProsCons
This food is certified USDA organic.Some pets dislike the turkey and vegetable option.
Each can is specially formulated with nutrient-rich superfoods.
This food is available in a variety of flavors and the number one ingredient in each one is organic free-range poultry.
It is completely free from pesticides, fertilizers, growth hormones, and artificial preservatives.
Best Canned
Castor & Pollux Organix Grain-Free Adult Canned Dog Food

•Free-range protein organic wet dog food

•Multiple flavor variations

•USDA approved

•No artificial ingredients

Check Chewy Check Amazon

4. Best Dehydrated Food: Dr. Harvey’s Canine Health Miracle Dog Food Pre-Mix

If you’re looking for dehydrated food for your dog then we suggest Dr. Harvey’s Canine Health Miracle Dog Food Pre-Mix.

This human-grade food is formulated with six organic grains, nine dehydrated vegetables, and crushed eggshells. It does not contain any fillers, chemicals, preservatives, or dye.

Designed to be a base to help you create a homemade meal for your dog, simply mix the dehydrated food with hot water to rehydrate it. Then, mix in fresh, raw meat and serve your dog a delectable dinner. The raw meat coupled with the nutrient-dense whole foods found in this formula can lead to an improved energy level, a healthier and shinier coat, and fewer skin issues.

With this 10-pound bag of dehydrated food, you can make 66-pounds of nourishing food for your dog. When you account for the raw food you’ll be adding in, you’ll be able to provide them many healthy and nutritious meals. However, this food is definitely a splurge and, if you decide to use this formula along with raw meat, make sure you have discussed the decision with your veterinarian beforehand.

However, if you want to try your pet out with a smaller bag before you take the plunge completely, you can purchase a five-pound bag instead. Despite this, the main drawback of this food is that it is expensive, and shelling out $82.00 on a bag of food might be a bit hard to stomach.

Pros and Cons of Dr. Harvey’s Canine Health Miracle Dog Food Pre-Mix

ProsCons
This human-grade food is formulated with six organic grains and nine dehydrated vegetables.At $82.00, this food is expensive.
The nutrient-rich ingredients are designed to improve energy level and coat health.
This food is designed to be a base for you to create a homemade meal for your dog. Simply add hot water and mix in raw meat.
Best Dehydrated Food
Dr. Harvey's Canine Health Miracle Dog Food

•Human-grade, dehydrated, organic dog food

•Easy use for healthy, happy dog

•Improved energy, shiny coat, healthy joints


Check Amazon

Our Criteria: How to Choose the Best Organic Dog Food

As we know, all dogs are different — different ages, sizes, breeds — as well as preferences and personalities. Some dogs have all of the energy in the world and could run miles upon miles outdoors while others choose the life of luxury on the couch. There are dogs that are highly picky in what foods they will eat and others that eat anything in sight. Based on the differing preferences and requirements for different dogs, it can be hard to choose a food that suits your unique pup perfectly, especially a food that is natural and free from harmful ingredients.

Before purchasing food for your dog, it is important to keep in mind that each food is different, and every dog has different needs. Use the key features below to help you compare different options and select the best food for your pup.

Breed, Size, and Activity Level

The nutritional needs of a 10-pound dog will clearly vary from those of a 100-pound dog. Likewise, different dog breeds have different nutritional needs. So, the first thing you should look for is whether each dog food option is a good match for your dog’s nutritional needs. Finding the right mix of nutrients is essential for helping dogs develop strong bones, a healthy immune system, and a shiny coat. It is also important for their mental health.

Since larger dogs have a slower metabolism, the right food for them will include a lot of higher-quality fats. Smaller dog breeds have a faster metabolism and need the right mix of vitamins and minerals to stay healthy.

Age

Age is another key factor when choosing food. The nutritional needs and calories goals vary quite a bit between foods for puppies versus foods for senior dogs. Many foods are specifically formulated for puppies, adults, or seniors. Use your dog’s age to help you select which formulation is right for your dog.

Ingredients

Next, take a close look at the ingredients in the food. Look for organic and natural ingredients that will help keep your pup healthy. Avoid dog foods that list fillers or other questionable ingredients.

If your dog has any allergies, you’ll also want to keep this in mind as you search for the right food. Stay away from foods that contain any known allergens. If you are unsure of which ingredients your dog may be allergic to, look for foods with just a few simple ingredients that may help you narrow down the problem.

Wet vs. Dry

You will also need to decide whether you’d prefer to feed your dog wet food or dry food. There are organic options available for each of these food types.

One advantage of wet food is that it can be easier to eat and digest for dogs since its moisture content is higher. This may make it a better choice if your dog has a sensitive stomach. Wet food is also easier for dogs who have lost teeth or are dealing with tooth pain. One negative aspect of wet food is that it may cause dogs to develop more dental problems. So, if your dog is prone to cavities or losing teeth, dry food may be better.

Budget

While we want to do what is best for our dogs, it is also important to stick within our budgets. Look for quality dog food that is also affordable. Choosing an affordable option may make it more realistic for you to continue to offer your dog organic food, while also providing him the other care he needs.

Veterinarian Recommendations

Finally, your veterinarian can be an excellent resource when you’re looking for the best dog food for your dog. They can help you compare brands and may have some other recommendations for you to try.

Wet vs. Dry Food: Pros and Cons Compared

Deciding between wet and dry dog food can be a challenge for some pet owners. Use the pros and cons for each food type outlined below to help you make a decision. Also, keep in mind that some pet owners decide to mix both wet and dry food together to take advantage of some of the benefits of each food type. When switching foods or looking into specific dietary needs, always consult your veterinarian prior to switching.

Dry Food

ProsCons
Easy to measure and feed May include more carbs and fewer fats
Lasts a long time so you can purchase in bulk Can be difficult to chew
Typically less expensive
Easier to travel with
Keep dog’s teeth cleaner than wet food

Wet Food

Cons
Easy to consume Requires refrigeration once open
Greater moisture content Doesn’t last as long
Higher amounts of protein Can cause increased plaque build up on teeth
More expensive

Best Organic Dog Food: Summary

There are many factors to consider when it comes to choosing food for your pet — and that’s before we even begin to think about organic food. However, it is important to choose what is right for your pet — whether that is wet or dry food. We hope that this product review has given you an insight into how to select the perfect food to deliver the nutrients your dog needs to thrive and live a happy, healthy life.

Up Next…

About the Author

My passion is writing about animals. I’ve published articles on pet parrots, birds, and small animal care and reviews about pet food and products. I have an ever-evolving aviary and menagerie that has included cockatiels, parakeets, conures, European starlings, a chukar partridge, guinea pigs, dogs, and cats. I’m also the author of Faith without Labels: a Guide to Eclectic Spirituality.

Best Organic Dog Food: Reviewed for You FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

What is organic dog food?

Organic dog food is food that is made using organic ingredients. In order to be classified as organic, ingredients must be grown without the use of synthetic fertilizers, pesticides, GMOs, sewage sludge, or ionizing radiation. Any dairy products, eggs, poultry, or meat found in the food must have been raised without any growth hormones or antibiotics.

There are three different categories of products classified by the United States Department of Agriculture. The first is 100% organic food. This food is made using all organic ingredients. The next category is organic food. This is made using at least 95% organic ingredients. The final category is “made with organic ingredients.” These foods must contain at least 70% organic ingredients. The other 30% of the ingredients must also meet restrictions, such as being GMO-free.

How much more does organic dog food cost?

The prices of dog food can vary from brand to brand. However, on average, organic dog food tends to cost about 23% more than regular food, though it may cost up to 40% as much as conventional dog food.

Is organic dog food better than regular dog food?

The decision over which type of food to feed your dog is a personal one. While studies indicate that the nutritional value of regular dog food is comparable to organic dog food, regular food may include more pesticide residue. You may decide that the best overall choice for your dog is organic food that will be free of these potentially harmful pesticide residues.

What ingredients should I avoid when buying dog food?

When you’re looking to purchase food for your dog, avoid any foods that contain the following ingredients: BHA, TBHQ, BHT, artificial dyes, propylene glycol, generic “meat,” menadione, ethoxyquin, and menadione. These ingredients are linked to health problems such as cancer, food allergies, and liver pigmentation.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us? Contact the AZ Animals editorial team.