The Best Chew Toys for Pit Bulls in 2022

Published: April 11, 2022

This post may contain affiliate links to our partners like Chewy, Amazon, and others. Purchasing through these helps us further the A-Z Animals mission to educate about the world's species..

Despite what people may think, pit bulls are an incredibly loving and sweet dog breed. They make wonderful pets and require similar maintenance as other larger breeds. Pitbulls need regular exercise and a variety of durable toys to withstand their muscular grip. 

Just like any other dog, if pits aren’t given enough attention or room to roam, they’ll start chewing on things like furniture, rugs, and anything else they can get a hold of. Pitbulls can’t necessarily use the same toys as any other dog because of their Hulk-like strength. 

To make it easier on pet owners like yourself, we’ve found the best chew toys for tough Pitbulls. You won’t have to worry about parts of the toy breaking off, potentially causing a choking hazard. 

From fun pull ropes to treat-concealing toys, here are our top picks for the best toys available to your four-legged friend and everything you need to know to choose the ideal option for Fido! 

Why Do Pitbulls Need Special Toys?

To be clear, chewing tendencies may be quite strong in canines of any breed. Some Chihuahuas are just as fast as your pit bull in chewing through a flimsy toy. Pit bulls, on the other hand, appear to have more consistent power-chewing habits than most other dogs. 

Pit bulls are neither ferocious, murderous, nor any of the other hyperbolic terms typically used to describe the breed. The bottom line is that their jaws are stronger and have a chewing power that can get through standard chew toys rather quickly. 

In order to find a toy your dog will love that won’t break immediately, it’s best to get a pitbull-specific toy. Here are a few other reasons you’ll want to avoid picking up just any toy off the shelf. 

Most Pit Bulls Have Bigger Heads

Although some little dogs can disassemble a tough toy in minutes, the majority of strong chewers have huge heads. Pit bulls weighing 40 to 50 pounds typically have heads the size of pups weighing twice that much. These bigger heads generally imply larger canine teeth, jaws, and muscles, which means disaster for delicate toys.

Their Jaws Are Wider

While the bigger dimensions of so many pit bull skulls contribute to higher jaw strength, the technical advantage provided by pit bulls’ comparatively broad jaws also contributes to their power-chewing skill. 

Since their jaws are frequently wider, they can exert greater leverage and tension on their toys, allowing them to quickly break down even the most robust objects

It’s in Their Blood

Early pit bulls were chosen for their desire to accomplish tasks despite unpleasant stimuli, a trait known as “gameness.” Back in the day, Pitties were chosen for their determination to fight through agony or injuries. 

Because dog toys don’t fight back, even an average pit bull will typically continue tearing it apart until their toy is completely destroyed. With that being said, let’s take a look at the toys that can withstand the strength of our favorite breed!

  1. KONG Extreme Goodie Bone Dog Toy
  2. KONG Extreme Goodie Bone Dog Toy
    • Great choice for aggressive chewers
    • Made in the USA
    • Super-sturdy construction
    • Trusted brand with quality materials
    • Available in medium and large sizes
    • Hide treats in the treat compartment
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  3. KONG Extreme Ball Dog Toy
  4. KONG Extreme Ball Dog Toy
    • Affordable pricetag
    • Made in the USA
    • Puncture-resistant construction
    • Durable materials stand up to aggressive chewers
    • Available in multiples sizes
    • Ideal for adult pits (not pups)
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  5. West Paw Zogoflex Jive Tough Ball
  6. West Paw Zogoflex Jive Tough Ball
    • Made of recycled materials
    • Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
    • Floats in water — great for water play
    • Made in the USA
    • Latex-free and FDA-compliant
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  7. Benebone Chicken Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy
  8. Benebone Chicken Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy
    • Nylon-based construction is highly durable
    • Paw-friendly design helps pups keep a solid grip
    • Flavored with real chicken
    • Percentage of purchase price is donated to animal welfare groups
    Check Chewy Check Amazon

1. Overall Best: Kong Extreme Goodie Bone Dog Toy 

The Kong Extreme Goodie Bone Dog Toy is ranked first on our list. This toy is perfect for aggressive chewers and may also be used for Pit Bull training. Because of its sturdiness and the reality that it’s created in the United States, this is our top overall pick among chew toys for Pit Bulls. 

KONG is a well-known brand that is beloved by dog owners that have larger pets. This chew toy is designed with ultra-durable rubber that will last through several chew sessions, all while being gentle on your dog’s teeth and gums. 

The nicest part about this chew toy, which comes in medium and large sizes, is that it has a compartment on each end where you can hide treats for your pit to discover. However, some pet owners have complained that the chew toy isn’t as strong as it should be.

The KONG Extreme is created with powerful chewers in mind and is composed of all-natural black rubber. The KONG Extreme Goodie Bone Dog Toy will keep your dog active and pleased. Overall, it’s our top pick and pet parents seem to agree! 

Best Overall
KONG Extreme Goodie Bone Dog Toy
  • Great choice for aggressive chewers
  • Made in the USA
  • Super-sturdy construction
  • Trusted brand with quality materials
  • Available in medium and large sizes
  • Hide treats in the treat compartment
Check Chewy Check Amazon

2. Best Budget: Kong Extreme Ball Dog Toy 

Kong has a second appearance on our list for the best chew toy for a pit bull that won’t break the bank! The Kong Extreme Ball Dog Toy is an affordable option that the company makes in the United States. 

Pet parents love that it’s puncture-resistant, making it great for long games of fetch or a tough chew session from your pit. The ball itself will withstand the strong jaws that pit bulls have. 

The ball, available in multiple sizes, bounces high in the air, making it easy to wear out your dog, leading to a well-deserved nap. Because of the weight of the ball, we do suggest this choice for adult pities. It may be too heavy for pups. 

Best Budget
KONG Extreme Ball Dog Toy
  • Affordable pricetag
  • Made in the USA
  • Puncture-resistant construction
  • Durable materials stand up to aggressive chewers
  • Available in multiples sizes
  • Ideal for adult pits (not pups)
Check Chewy Check Amazon

3. Best for Puppies: West Paw Zogoflex Jive Tough Ball Dog Toy

If your dog loves chasing and chewing toy balls, the West Paw Zogoflex Jive Tough Ball Dog Toy is a must-try! One of our favorite aspects of this toy is that it’s made with recycled materials. 

It’s much more durable than a tennis ball and has a unique shape that makes gameplay much more fun for your canine. This ball is available in three different colors including orange, blue, and green. 

The dishwasher-safe dog toy from West Paw floats in water, making it an incredibly fun toy for the warm summer months! Pet parents also appreciate that it comes in a variety of sizes, making it easy to find one that will fit your pit. The smallest size fits in a dog ball thrower if you already have one of those toys. 

If you have a senior dog or a pooch with mobility challenges, it’s best to avoid the West Paw Zogoflex Jive Tough Ball Dog Toy since it’s quite heavy. 

This ball is heavier than expected, so it might not be the best choice for elderly or mobility-challenged pet owners. It’s also been reported as being easy to destroy if you have a really aggressive chewer.

You can easily clean this ball chew by placing it on the top rack of your dishwasher. Made in the United States, this recyclable dog ball toy is FDA-compliant, latex-free, and backed by the manufacturer’s “Love It Guarantee” for breakage.

Best for Puppies
West Paw Zogoflex Jive Tough Ball
  • Made of recycled materials
  • Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
  • Floats in water — great for water play
  • Made in the USA
  • Latex-free and FDA-compliant
Check Chewy Check Amazon

4. Best Flavored: Benebone Rotisserie Chicken Flavored Wishbone

For dogs who are fussy about their chew toys, the Benebone Flavored Wishbone is a terrific alternative. Not only are these nylon-based bones highly durable, but they’re also flavored with real chicken.

The Wishbone of Benebone Chew isn’t your typical chew toy for your dog. The ergonomic wishbone, American-made from sturdy nylon and authentic USA-sourced chicken throughout, will keep your dog chewing happily! Distinctive flavor channels on each prong keep Fido intrigued, and the unusual, paw-friendly design makes grasping a breeze. 

As if that weren’t enough, Benebone donates a percentage of each purchase to animal welfare groups around the country, so your purchase will also help animals in need! Dogs across the board love the taste and you won’t have to worry about chunks breaking off and potentially causing harm. This toy slowly breaks down, providing a long-lasting chew! 

Best Flavored
Benebone Chicken Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy
  • Nylon-based construction is highly durable
  • Paw-friendly design helps pups keep a solid grip
  • Flavored with real chicken
  • Percentage of purchase price is donated to animal welfare groups
Check Chewy Check Amazon

Choosing the Best: What to Look For

Here are the criteria we suggest to select the ideal toys for Pitbulls. We didn’t review cutesy, fluffy items with squeakers that may be ripped out and choked on. 

We didn’t include rope toys since they are the pit equivalent of single-use dental floss. Anything that might be pulled up and eaten is out of our choosing, as these items can become lodged in the dog’s bowel, necessitating surgery to remove them.

Dog’s Temperament and Age

We would not want to offer a heavy chewer a soft toy. Noisy toys are also not a suitable choice for frightened dogs or those that are sensitive to loud noises. Please ensure the toy you choose is appropriate for your dog’s temperament. 

You’ll also want to make sure that the chew toy you’re considering is appropriate for your pet’s age. The greatest dog toys specify the age range for which the toy is appropriate. Hard toys are best for mature dogs since puppy teeth can be harmed.

Toy Type

If you have a lively dog or a teething puppy, a dog toy ball is ideal. Chew toys, on the other hand, are the greatest alternative for younger dogs and those that chew on furniture. Rope toys are a wonderful way for you and your pet to bond. 

Stuffed toys are a great option if you want a basic toy that is absolutely safe and soft on your pet’s teeth. If you really want to stimulate your pet, puzzles might be an excellent solution. Your dog will have to learn how to rotate and spin parts of the puzzle to retrieve treats.

Durability

The last thing you want to buy a pit bull is a flimsy chewy toy. Look for something made with durable materials, such as nylon or hard rubber. We all know how fast a pit can destroy his favorite toy and finding a sturdier option makes the toy last longer, saving you money. 

Flavors

As you saw in our reviews, some of the best chew toys for pits come with flavoring. Pit bulls love a tasty treat as much as the next breed. Getting a chewy toy with flavoring is a great way to entice your dog to play with that specific toy over something they’re not supposed to nibble on, like your new sofa! 

The Different Types of Chewy Toys for Pitbulls: Pros and Cons Compared

Now that you’re one step closer to being an expert on the best chew toys for pit bulls, here’s a guide to finding the best type for your pooch. Dog toys are designed using a variety of materials. This is the main factor you want to look for when comparing one toy to another. 

While there are different styles of chews, such as balls, ropes, rings, etc, the material is far more important. Let’s take a look at the benefits and disadvantages of the main components used to make dog toys. 

  • Hard rubber: This is a top option for chew toys and might be the closest thing to an unbreakable dog toy. Kong Toys is an excellent example. Kong toys are composed of strong rubber and have a hollow core. They come in a variety of different designs and shapes.
  • Sterilized hollow bones: This is a safe chew toy for your adult dog. This type of treat has natural cow shin bone and dogs love the taste! Because it is a bone, don’t expect it to last that long.  
  • Plush textile: This makes the plush toy soft enough for gentle gnawing and comfortable enough for your pet to sit on or sleep on. It’s not a good chew toy for pit bulls since they’ll demolish it in under a minute. 
  • Wood: Puzzle toys constructed of wood can be used as a brain stimulant for dogs. It’s worth noting that they might result in splinters.
  • Hard plastic: Nylabone Toys are made of a sturdy substance that is ideal for teething. It’s a great choice for puppies but may be too weak for adult pit bulls.
  • Rope fibers: A braided rope toy’s fibrous properties ensure that it will survive many playtimes before breaking down. A tough pit bull may be able to destroy a rope faster than another material such as hard rubber. 

Verified Review: User Experience

How do you know which one of these dog toys is worth your hard-earned money? We always suggest taking a look at reviews to get the best idea of how real-life pet parents like the product. 

For our top choice, the Kong Extreme Goodie Bone, one Amazon user has this to say: “This KONG Extreme Black Goodie Bone Dog Toy is the perfect toy for your big dog or super chewer. The black KONG toys are the thickest and most durable of all their toys, and they can really take a beating! We have had this toy for our large breed shepherd/pit mix, who uses it almost every day and it is still in excellent condition!”

It’s essential to find a toy that will last a long time. Even the Benebone Wishbone Tough Chew Toy is up for the challenge, despite it having a flavoring of drool-worthy chicken! Here’s what one pet parent has to say on Chewy:

“Our one-year-old Pit mix is a heavy chewer. The Benebone is his favorite and lasts the longest. This wishbone shape is working out better than the others for him. He only is able to get small pieces off of the bone at a time.”

Products For This Review

About the Author

When she's not busy playing with her several guinea pigs, 14-year-old dog, or her cat Spirit, Kirstin is writing articles to help other pet owners. She's also a REALTOR® in the Twin Cities and is passionate about social justice. There's nothing that beats a rainy day with a warm cup of tea and Frank Sinatra on vinyl for this millennial.

The Best Chew Toys for Pit Bulls in 2022 FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

What causes dogs to pull the stuffing out of toys? 

Since stuffed animals resemble natural prey, dogs pull the stuffing out of them. As a result, these toys may arouse the dog’s hunt-and-kill instinct. Another possibility is that the dog is simply attempting to avoid boredom.



Is it unhealthy for dogs to chew on hard chew toys? 

Yes, particularly hard chew toys can cause tooth damage in your dog. Try making an impression on the toy’s exterior with your nail to see whether it’s too hard.



Is it okay if I leave my dog's toys outside? 

Whether you hide the toys or keep them visible to your dog is entirely up to you. If your pet like the toy, we recommend leaving it out all of the time. If you’re worried that your dog would damage it, put it away and take it out when your dog is wanting to play with it.



Is it okay if my dog destroys his toys? 

Even if toy destruction appears to be innocuous, you should prevent it. Toy destruction may be dangerous to your dog’s health, it can be costly, and it will likely encourage your dog to destroy other objects in your home.



Do dogs need toys?

Toys are important for dogs since they serve to stimulate their minds. They also offer them something to gnaw on and provide them with comfort when they are worried. Furthermore, toys can aid in the prevention of undesired habits in your dog.



More from A-Z Animals