9 Best Kept Secret Places to Retire In Indiana

Indiana is an essential component of the Midwest. The Hoosier State’s natural beauty is something to behold. With around 5 million acres of forest, it’s an outdoor enthusiast’s dream. Locals are also treated to numerous lakes, prairies, caves, and wetlands. Indiana shares borders with Michigan, Ohio, and Kentucky, with access to Lake Michigan. Therefore, there are many amazing places to retire in the Hoosier State. Indiana has everything, whether you are looking for small-town charm, historical and cultural attractions, or picturesque retirement villages. Below is a list of the best-kept secret places to retire in Indiana and what they have to offer.

1. Anderson 

The town of Anderson was founded in 1827 and has a population of around 55,000 people. However, it manages to maintain a small-town feel and serene atmosphere. But, it’s the cultural attractions that draw in most retirees. For example, the town is home to 32 buildings of historical significance. People can explore these buildings in the Historic District. However, if history is not your thing, Hoosier Park offers casino games and horse racing. Anderson is also attractive to seniors because of its climate. Summers are hot, but winters are mild, so residents can enjoy the outdoors throughout the year.

2. Marion

Marion is one of the best places to retire in Indiana. It has a population of around 30,000 people and is the seat of Grant County. Retirees are attracted to this quaint town’s fascinating history and natural beauty while still providing the comforts of modern living. Two of the most popular historical attractions in Marion are the Grant County Jail and the Marion Downtown Commercial Historic District. However, the town caters to outdoor enthusiasts as well. For example, the Cardinal Greenway trail is perfect for birdwatching, biking, and walking. Furthermore, Marion is notorious for its yearly Christmas Parade, which boasts colorful floats, and Old Saint Nick himself.

3. East Chicago

The town of East Chicago in Indiana is only 18 miles from Chicago, situated near the Illinois border. It has a population of approximately 26,000 residents. East Chicago is a pleasant and, most importantly, affordable place to retire. This hidden gem is located along Lake Michigan, with great opportunities for swimming and sailing. It is also popular for its proximity to Chicago, so residents have the best of both worlds.

4. Connersville

Connersville is a quaint town with all the amenities and luxuries of big-city life. It is home to around 13,000 people and is one of the state’s oldest settlements, spanning back to 1813. The town has a lot of historical significance since it is located along the Whitewater River, and several landmarks in Connersville are included in the National Register of Historic Places. The landmarks include Elmhurst Mansion and Canal House. Additionally, the town has a few beautiful natural areas like the Doc-O-Lake Recreation Area and Manlove Park.

5. Gary

Gary has a population of around 68,000 people and is known for its natural beauty, affordable housing, and historic charm. This quaint town sits on Lake Michigan’s shores, offering residents and visitors numerous opportunities for boating, swimming, and lazy walks on the shoreline. Furthermore, retirees can explore the Dunes National Park, which has over 20 miles of breathtaking nature and wildlife. Additionally, you can explore several historic landmarks and buildings, like the birthplace of the King of Pop, Michael Jackson, and the Gary City Center Historic District.

6. New Castle

New Castle is the seat of Henry County and sits along the 84-mile-long Big Blue River. The town is home to approximately 17,000 people. It is one of the best places to retire in Indiana because of its charming natural surroundings and affordable housing. New Castle residents spend their time outdoors at places like the Summit Lake State Park, where they can bike, fish, hike, and take in some bird watching.

7. Logansport

Logansport is located at the Wabash and Eel Rivers meeting point and is the seat of Cass County. It has a small population of over 18,000 residents, so this historic town is very quiet, making it one of the best places to retire in Indiana. Logansport was founded in 1826; therefore, it has a lot of historic landmarks and buildings on the National Register of Historic Places, including the Courthouse Historic District and Ferguson House. Additionally, the town hosts numerous festivals, like Art of the Avenue. It also boasts waterside access and beautiful park areas.

8. Muncie

Muncie is only a 50-mile drive from Indianapolis and dates back to 1827 when it was first established. It has a population of around 65,000 people, so while it’s a relatively small town, it still has all the amenities and comforts of big-city living. It’s the perfect place for retirees due to its many natural and cultural attractions, including the David Owsley Museum of Art, Oakhurst Gardens, and the National Model Aviation Museum. Furthermore, Muncie has an affordable housing market, so retirees can enjoy their lives without stressing about money. This mid-sized town also has some nearby wineries, so you can spend your days sampling some of Indiana’s best local wines.

9. Carmel

Carmel is one of the best places to live in the U.S., with its charming and affluent neighborhoods. This mid-sized town has a population of around 100,700 people and a vibrant community. The town offers retirees a welcoming and secure environment, with its extensive network of walking trails, parks, and green spaces they can enjoy at their own pace. Carmel also has an excellent cultural scene and hosts various outdoor concerts, festivals, and theatre. In fact, this town is home to a world-class concert hall, the Palladium. This concert hall hosts symphonies and renowned musicians, ensuring there is always entertainment for the locals.

But, what really makes Carmel one of the best places to retire in Indiana is its focus on senior-friendly amenities, like senior centers that provide recreational and social programs tailored specifically to the interests and needs of older adults. These centers frequently organize activities like educational seminars, fitness classes, and social gatherings, creating a sense of companionship and community among seniors.

Summary of the 9 Best Kept Secret Places to Retire in Indiana

The photo featured at the top of this post is © David Wilson / CC BY 2.0 – License / Original