The Best Gentle Leader Head Collar — Reviewed and Ranked

Written by Kristin Hitchcock
Updated: December 13, 2022
©

This post may contain affiliate links to our partners like Chewy, Amazon, and others. Purchasing through these helps us further the A-Z Animals mission to educate about the world's species..

Key Points

  • The #1 Best Overall gentle leader head collar is the PetSafe Gentle Leader Head Collar.
  • Using a gentle leader head collar can prevent dogs from exhibiting negative behaviors when going for a walk in public by guiding the dog’s attention away from distractions and back to its owner. It should be constructed of durable fabric to withstand wear and tear and be fitted comfortably around your dog’s neck and upper nose area.
  • We researched many products before creating our list. Based on our search, we selected the most durable, comfortable, adjustable, and eye-catching models that teach your dogs not to react to distractions.

Teaching a dog to walk on a leash is one of the most challenging tasks. The training process may be very easy for some dogs but may seem impossible for others. In order to make walking their dogs a bit easier, many people use gentle leader head collars. 

Gentle leader head collars look like muzzles to some people, but they’re not designed to silence your dog. During pulling, a nose loop guides your dog’s head to turn toward you. This will refocus your dog’s attention on you, instead of whatever was distracting it or causing it to pull. As it sits high on your dog’s neck, this type of collar doesn’t prevent your dog from panting or barking.

Barking, lunging, and jumping are all behaviors that can be prevented by these collars. You can also use them to train your dog to heel with them. With them, you can handle your dog much more easily than with a traditional leash. Many people use these collars for training and then switch to a different option following training. 

We have reviewed the best gentle leader head collars available on the market to help you find the best one!

  1. PetSafe Gentle Leader Padded No Pull Dog Headcollar
  2. PetSafe Gentle Leader Padded No Pull Dog Headcollar
    • Designed with a neoprene padded nose loop
    • Perfect for preventing pulling, lunging, and jumping
    • Put pressure on the back of your dog's neck, which prevents coughing and choking
    • Makes your dog easier to control
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  3. PetSafe Gentle Leader Chic Padded Dog Headcollar & Leash
  4. PetSafe Gentle Leader Chic Padded Dog Headcollar & Leash
    • More stylish than the plain black headcollars
    • The nose loop is designed to gently guide your dog away from triggers
    • The closure type is a quick release
    • The extra padding makes it more gentle than other options
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  5. MPP Gentle Leader Head Dog Collar
  6. MPP Gentle Leader Head Dog Collar
    • Comes with a comprehensive training DVD
    • The collar is extremely adjustable
    • If you want to train your dog, this is a very good option
    • The training guide will help you wean off your dog from a head collar
    Check Amazon
  7. wintchuk Dog Head Collar
  8. wintchuk Dog Head Collar
    • Durable and practical
    • Simple design
    • Reflective, making it easier for your dog to be seen at night
    • Multiple different styles available
    Check Amazon

Top Picks: The Best Gentle Leader Head Collars Today

#1. Best Overall: PetSafe Gentle Leader Padded No Pull Headcollar

As our overall choice, the PetSafe Gentle Leader Head Collar is perfect for preventing pulling, lunging, and jumping. When you’re training or walking a dog that’s very reactive or difficult to handle, it can be very useful. As a bonus, it also gives your dog a lot of practice walking without any of these negative behaviors arising. 

Featuring a neoprene nose loop for added comfort, this collar prevents chafing on dogs’ noses. Additionally, it prevents coughing and choking by placing pressure on the back of your dog’s neck. Your dog can also be controlled more easily since he cannot pull so strongly against the leash. 

There are multiple sizes available for this collar, and the nose loop allows you to adjust it for the perfect fit. The buckle broke easily for some dog owners, but this was not the consensus among all dog owners. Nevertheless, we thought it was important to note for your purchasing expectations.

Pros and Cons of the PetSafe Gentle Leader Padded No Pull Headcollar

ProsCons
The padded neoprene nose loop places pressure on the neck rather than the throat of your dog.Some dog owners had problems with the buckle breaking easily.
By wearing this head collar, you can teach better leash behavior to your pup.
This collar is available in multiple sizes to fit a wide variety of dogs.
Best Overall
PetSafe Gentle Leader Padded No Pull Dog Headcollar
  • Designed with a neoprene padded nose loop
  • Perfect for preventing pulling, lunging, and jumping
  • Put pressure on the back of your dog's neck, which prevents coughing and choking
  • Makes your dog easier to control
Check Chewy Check Amazon

2. Best Fashionable: PetSafe Leader Chic Padded Dog Headcollar & Leash

This PetSafe Leader Chic Padded Dog Headcollar & Leash may be your best bet if you’re looking for something more fashionable.

There are several different designs to choose from. Because of this, it tends to be a bit more stylish than a plain black head collar. This feature is, however, a bit more expensive, so you’ll have to pay a bit more. 

Your dog will be gently guided away from triggers with the nose loop. It does so, however, without choking or coughing. As a result of the extra padding, it is much gentler than other options. 

There is a quick-release closure, so taking it off and putting it on is very easy. As you’re probably not going to leave this on your dog over time, this buckle makes it easier to remove between walks. 

Pros and Cons of the PetSafe Leader Chic Padded Dog Headcollar & Leash

ProsCons
You can choose from a variety of fashionable options to keep your dog looking stylish.It’s a bit pricey compared to other head collars.
Provides gentle, safe control of unwanted leash behavior.
To make the collar more comfortable and gentle, there is extra padding on the collar.
Best Fashionable
PetSafe Gentle Leader Chic Padded Dog Headcollar & Leash
  • More stylish than the plain black headcollars
  • The nose loop is designed to gently guide your dog away from triggers
  • The closure type is a quick release
  • The extra padding makes it more gentle than other options
Check Chewy Check Amazon

3. Best for Training: MPP Gentle Leader Head Dog Collar

Choosing the MPP Gentle Leader Head Dog Collar is an excellent option if you’re looking for professional guidance when training your dog.

This head collar and training guide is a great choice for dog owners looking to train their pets. A training guide is included to help you use the head collar correctly and provide additional training advice. In case you don’t plan on using a head collar forever, this dog training guide will show you how to wean your dog off of it. 

In contrast to most other collar options, this collar comes with a comprehensive training DVD. If you’re new to head collars, this DVD is a great place to start. Moreover, this collar is extremely adjustable, so your dog can wear it comfortably. Furthermore, the collar is available in a wide range of sizes to fit dogs weighing as little as 25 pounds to as much as 130 pounds. 

When some dog owners tried to put on the leash for the first time, they found it difficult to do. Fortunately, it comes with pictured instructions. 

Pros and Cons of the MPP Gentle Leader Head Dog Collar

ProsCons
A comprehensive training DVD teaches you how to use a gentle leader head collar.The collar can be difficult to put on at first for some dog owners.
There are several sizes available, starting with small and going up to extra large.
As a starting point for training a dog, this is an excellent option.
Best for Training
MPP Gentle Leader Head Dog Collar
  • Comes with a comprehensive training DVD
  • The collar is extremely adjustable
  • If you want to train your dog, this is a very good option
  • The training guide will help you wean off your dog from a head collar
Check Amazon

4. Best Value: wintchuk Dog Head Collar

Getting the wintchuk Dog Head Collar is a great way to get the best value for your money.

In general, head collars are more expensive than other collars because they contain more material. In contrast to other options we’ve mentioned thus far, this head collar is much less expensive. It is quite durable and practical, which makes it a good choice for those looking for a cheaper alternative.

Head collars like this one have a fairly simple design. For extra durability, it is made with 11 seams. In addition, it is reflective, which makes them easier to see at night. It is crucial that you consider this safety aspect if you usually walk your dog at night. 

In addition to three different sizes, there are multiple different styles to choose from. As a result, you can use these for a variety of dogs with different sides. Moreover, each comes with a variety of adjustment points and lengths, so you can get the perfect fit for your dog. In spite of the collar’s ability to be adjusted, some dog owners have noted that it doesn’t work well with dogs with short snouts.

Pros and Cons of the wintchuk Dog Head Collar

ProsCons
A fabric padded nose area prevents irritation.The collar will not fit dogs with short snouts.
The perfect fit is ensured with adjustable lengths.
The head collar is a great value for the price.
Best for the Money
wintchuk Dog Head Collar
  • Durable and practical
  • Simple design
  • Reflective, making it easier for your dog to be seen at night
  • Multiple different styles available
Check Amazon

How to Choose the Best Gentle Leader Head Collar

At the end of the day, we all want our furry friend to be comfortable and well-mannered. This is especially true when we go out for walks with them where other people will be present. When it comes down to training your dog, it can be a stressful process. Especially if they happen to constantly pull on their leash. With gentle leader head collars, you can train your furry best friend without causing them any discomfort! There are, however, a few things you need to consider before buying a head collar.

Choosing the best gentle leader head collar for your pup requires consideration of three main factors:

  • Adjustability 
  • Ease of use 
  • Durability 

In the following sections, we will examine each of these factors in more detail:

Adjustability

Unless a head collar fits your dog properly, it will not work. You will rarely find a head collar that fits your dog perfectly without any adjustments. Therefore, you should choose a feature that can be easily and accurately adjusted. It is essential to make sure the head collar fits as well as possible before you use it.

Ease of Use

It is common for dogs to dislike wearing head collars, at least at first. Getting the dog used to the collar takes some time. Consequently, you don’t want to be struggling with the collar at the same time as you’re already struggling with your dog. To make the process easier for both of them, it must be easy to put on and take off. You should be able to adjust the buckle easily and put it on and take it off quickly.

Durability

If you’re buying a gentle leader head collar, then your dog is probably reactive, so he or she will pull on it. Therefore, we recommend finding a head collar that can withstand this pulling and is quite durable. You should look for a head collar that has multiple seams and is made from quality materials.

Up Next…

The Best Gentle Leader Head Collar — Reviewed and Ranked FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

How is a head halter different from a gentle leader?

There is a difference between halters and gentle leaders, even though they may look similar. Each of these alternative leashes has several key differences. Here’s a quick rundown:

  • Halters fit more loosely. Many dogs tolerate these head collars better for this reason. However, this also means that halters are easier for your dog to escape than a gentle leader. If your dog is a bit more rambunctious, then you may want to consider a gentle leader over a halter.
  • Gentle leaders are more adjustable. Halters are much harder to adjust and may not fit all dogs. However, gentle leaders are far easier to use and adjust. You can usually get them to fit most dogs pretty easily.
  • Halters have different ring locations. Halters have a ring right under the dog’s chin, which makes it easier to control the dog and prevents the risk that you’ll turn their head too sharply, which can cause injuries. In other words, halters are safer in this regard.
  • Gentle leaders are more varied. This type of head collar has been around forever, so there are a lot more different options available than head halters. For this reason, there is a higher likelihood that you’ll find the right product for you. Furthermore, there are also more training resources available, which is vital for proper use.
  • Gentle leaders are easier to get off and on. They are designed with easy buckles and can be slipped on and off easier. Therefore, even if your dog doesn’t love these head collars, they are much easier to utilize.
  • Gentle leaders are (surprise!) more gentle. While they don’t provide you as much control over your dog’s movements, they are much gentler and less likely to cause injury. Therefore, they are better for those that don’t want to spend much time learning how to use them. Unlike a halter, they aren’t likely to cause injury when used incorrectly.

Are head collars for dogs cruel?

Since head collars fit differently than other collars, there is some debate about whether or not they are cruel. It is important to note, however, that head collars should not cause any pain or discomfort when they are used correctly. It should not be painful or irritating to wear these collars if they are fitted properly.

It is possible to cause slight problems with some head collars if they are misused. As an example, you need to avoid jerking when wearing a head collar, since this could cause minor injury and pain. It is important to note, however, that gentle leader head harnesses are not terribly abrasive, even if you do not use them correctly. There is a reason they are called gentle.

Why shouldn’t you use a gentle leader?

Gentle leaders should not be used for all dogs for several reasons. There are times when they just aren’t appropriate. First of all, these collars are only meant for walking. You cannot keep them on your dog at all times. As a result, your dog will also require a separate collar for other occasions.

In addition, gentle leaders do not train the dog themselves. They work best when used alongside training techniques that can reduce your dog’s reactive behavior. It’s a band-aid, not a solution. It is still possible for your dog to be reactive when you start using a gentle leader without training. Until your dog is properly trained, you will need to use a gentle leader every time.

Is a gentle leader good for dogs?

A gentle leader is a basic training tool. They are neither good nor bad. What matters is how you use them. Consequently, they can be an effective training tool for getting your dog more time walking before he or she is fully trained with a leash. Using a gentle leader too much, however, may result in your dog never walking properly while wearing a regular collar.

Furthermore, if you pull too hard on the gentle leader, it may snap your dog’s neck around too quickly. Injuries shouldn’t occur, however, as long as you use it properly.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us? Contact the AZ Animals editorial team.