The Top High Protein Cat Food For a Healthy Pet

Written by Alan
Updated: October 7, 2022

This post may contain affiliate links to our partners like Chewy, Amazon, and others. Purchasing through these helps us further the A-Z Animals mission to educate about the world's species..

Being a cat owner, you are either always enchanted by your cat’s adorable antics or worried about its well-being. But that is understandable. Making sure that your cat is at its healthiest includes keeping them active with toys for exercise, but also it is important to make sure your pet has a nutritious diet.

Since cats are known carnivores, they need a diet that is rich in proteins. You can either let it run after rats in the neighborhood or provide it with high-protein cat food. The latter is a less messy alternative. 

However, with hundreds of internet claims of being the best cat food, which one do you pick? This is why we are here. We have reviewed 5 high-protein cat food items that are healthy for your cat and ones that it will love eating!

A-Z-Animals Top Picks for High Protein Cat Food

  1. Tiki Cat Bora Bora Grill Sardine Cutlets in Lobster Consomme
  2. Tiki Cat Bora Bora Grill Sardine Cutlets in Lobster Consomme
    • 11% protein content
    • Sardine is the prime ingredient
    • Rich in omega fatty acids
    • Certified for human consumption
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  3. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
  4. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
    • Available in both dry and wet options
    • Grain-free
    • Added antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals
    • Made with natural ingredients
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  5. Wellness CORE Natural Grain-Free Turkey & Chicken Liver Pate Canned Kitten Food
  6. Wellness CORE Natural Grain-Free Turkey & Chicken Liver Pate Canned Kitten Food
    • Perfect for easy digestion
    • Easily chewable
    • Added vitamins and minerals
    • Contains DHA for brain and eye development
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  7. Purina ONE Ideal Weight Adult Dry Cat Food
  8. Purina ONE Ideal Weight Adult Dry Cat Food
    • Budget-friendly option
    • Grain-free
    • Contains mix of protein, minerals, and fats
    • Trusted brand by vets
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  9. Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
  10. Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
    • Contains mix of venison and salmon meat
    • Contains fruits, vegetables, minerals, and vitamins
    • Easily digestible
    • Boost the immune system
    Check Chewy Check Amazon

#1 Best Overall: Tiki Cat Grilled Sardine Can Cat Food

On the top of the list and the best overall is the Tiki Cat Grilled Sardine Can Cat Food. It is a premium choice for pet owners because of its nutritious formula. It has a high protein content, 11%, which is the most in canned cat food.

Moreover, the formula hosts sardine as its prime ingredient which is a high-protein animal source. That combined with the lobster broth aids this cat food to be extra hydrated for your cats. Plus, it is rich in omega fatty acids that help your furry buddy in gaining that extra toughness to tackle the world. It is also known to help with the cat’s coat and in strengthening the joints. This is a major plus point for cats with arthritis. 

Best Overall
Tiki Cat Bora Bora Grill Sardine Cutlets in Lobster Consomme
  • 11% protein content
  • Sardine is the prime ingredient
  • Rich in omega fatty acids
  • Certified for human consumption
Check Chewy Check Amazon

#2 Best for Adult Cats – Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken 

The second choice on our list is a favorite amongst all adult cats, the Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken recipe. The best thing about this cat food is that it is available in both dry and wet recipes. The formula contains a mix of real chicken and grain-free ingredients like sweet potato and peas. 

Another main attraction of this item is that it comprises a blend of nutritional ingredients to provide a healthy option for cats. This blend includes antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals for a boost in immunity. In addition, it is available in a bag of different sizes to either store in bulk or to feed multiple cats.  

Best for Adult Cats
Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
  • Available in both dry and wet options
  • Grain-free
  • Added antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals
  • Made with natural ingredients
Check Chewy Check Amazon

#3 Best for Kittens – Wellness CORE Natural 

If you have a kitten, the anxiety levels increase when trying out new products. But this Wellness CORE Natural is the top choice for kittens. Its nutritious formula is made up of cranberries, healthy fats, minerals, vitamins, fruits, vegetables, and of course, the star ingredient, meat. This blend of ingredients is perfect for easy digestion, boosting immunity, and providing strength to the eyes and teeth.

In addition, the moisture present in this cat food is a great way to keep the kittens hydrated. The moisture also turns the cat food into soft, easily chewable food for the kittens to easily eat their meal. 

Best for Kittens
Wellness CORE Natural Grain-Free Turkey & Chicken Liver Pate Canned Kitten Food
  • Perfect for easy digestion
  • Easily chewable
  • Added vitamins and minerals
  • Contains DHA for brain and eye development
Check Chewy Check Amazon

#4 Best Value – Purina ONE Adult Ideal Weight High Protein

Being on a budget and still want the best for your cat reduces your options. But the Purina ONE Adult Ideal Weight makes that job easier. This grain-free formula is rich in protein content and can help overweight cats to reduce weight. It is a healthy alternative containing a mix of protein, minerals, fats, vitamins, calcium, and fatty acids. 

If your cat has different preferences, you can try out different textured options available with this product; wet and dry cat food. Being a budget-friendly option, it does not compromise on its quality. It is a trusted brand by vets and promotes a healthy life with good metabolism for cats. 

Best Value
Purina ONE Ideal Weight Adult Dry Cat Food
  • Budget-friendly option
  • Grain-free
  • Contains mix of protein, minerals, and fats
  • Trusted brand by vets
Check Chewy Check Amazon

#5 Best Natural – Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain 

The Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain is last on our list but it is the best natural cat food. It carries a high nutritional content due to the unique mix of venison and salmon meat. The formula is further infused with different fruits, vegetables, minerals, and vitamins found in the wild. Together, they make a superformula that is easily digestible for cats.

In addition, this cat food is trusted to boost the immune system, metabolism, and overall energy of the cat. It aims to provide the same health to the cat as it would find in nature, only in refined form. 

Best Natural
Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
  • Contains mix of venison and salmon meat
  • Contains fruits, vegetables, minerals, and vitamins
  • Easily digestible
  • Boost the immune system
Check Chewy Check Amazon

Choosing the Best High-Protein Cat Food: What to Look For?

When purchasing high-protein cat food, there are some factors that you need to consider. Here is a brief description so you can avoid buying low-quality cat food.

Source of Protein 

Cats are carnivores and while soy-based proteins are good as additional nutrients, they are not what your cat needs. Hence, you should always pick cat food that contains meat, eggs, fish, or poultry. Because they have all the amino acids that your cat needs for a healthy diet. 

Cat’s Lifestyle

All cats have a different diet as per their age and preferences. Although their preferences might be subjective, their age has specific needs. Some older cats require a diet with omega fatty acids. Similarly, kittens need a diet with a much more nutritious diet than others. Moreover, there are cats that are overweight or infected with certain diseases. Hence, you must take this into account before buying cat food. 

Price

Another important factor is price. Many cat food products are quite expensive but they do not have a formula that is better than their cheaper alternatives. The main thing you can focus on for budget-friendly high-protein cat food is finding a common protein like chicken, fish, or meat. 

Different Types of Cat Food: Pros and Cons Compared

Of course, you want what is best for your pet, but before you decide on the best high-protein cat food, it is essential to know what type of cat food your cat may want. Basically, there are a few types, let’s see the pros and cons of each type.

 Dry Cat Food

Pros!Cons!
Contains a nutrient-rich formulaHard to chew for some cats
Easy to feedMay restrict water intake due to dry and crunchy bites
Easy to store

 Wet Cat Food

Pros!Cons!
Huge variety of textures  (chunky, heavy, flaked, broth, pureed, shredded, etc.) May contribute to weight gain.
Soft consistency with hydrated formula 

Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

Pros!Cons!
Does not need to be refrigerated. Requires rehydration before serving
High-protein option.

 Frozen Raw Cat Food

Pros!Cons!
High-protein optionMore expensive than other options
Made to resemble the wild cat’s intake. May be harder to prepare the formula. 

Verified Review: User Experience

Our top choice, the Smalls Human-Grade Fresh Bird had a few complaints about its price, but the customers loved the value it offered. David of Colorado says, “My cats love the food, and I’m happy to give them food that I am confident in being really healthy for them!”

The Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken mostly has a 5-star review on its profile. However, some people have complained about its expensive price. According to Auzia Clark, “It costs more than many other brands but is so worth it.”

Runosai calls Wellness CORE Natural a “wonder food for kitten”. She says, “On this food she’s shot up like a weed in the last three months, her coat is now the most healthy coat of my 3 cats, her eyes are bright, and she has a lot of energy – maybe too much.”

As for the Purina ONE Adult Ideal Weight High Protein, it gathered positive reviews for its high metabolism. Kylee says, “My cat is kinda fat so he was on some super expensive food..he lost the weight and decided to try this out. Oh my he loves this food.” 

Best Value
Purina ONE Ideal Weight Adult Dry Cat Food
  • Budget-friendly option
  • Grain-free
  • Contains mix of protein, minerals, and fats
  • Trusted brand by vets
Check Chewy Check Amazon

Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain has attracted a lot of positive ratings due to its all-natural diet. Chasing the Nichols says, “We’ve found the taste of the wild to be the best value for the quality of the ingredients.”

Products for This Review

About the Author

Alan is a freelance writer and an avid traveler. He specializes in travel content. When he visits home he enjoys spending time with his family Rottie, Opie.

The Top High Protein Cat Food For a Healthy Pet FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

Is high protein cat food good for cats?

Yes. Because of the high protein content in cat food, it is easily digestible and helps in reducing obesity.

What percentage of protein should cat food be?

Generally, it depends on your cat. However, 26% is considered a solid protein percentage in cat food.

What happens if a cat has too much protein?

It neither harms the cat nor benefits it. All the excess protein will eventually convert into urine and pass out of the cat’s body.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us? Contact the AZ Animals editorial team.