These Are the Best Peanut Butters for Dogs in 2022

Published: April 26, 2022

This post may contain affiliate links to our partners like Chewy, Amazon, and others. Purchasing through these helps us further the A-Z Animals mission to educate about the world's species..

There is a reason some dogs can’t get enough peanut butter. It appeals to your dog in two fundamental ways: lick and smell. 

Licking is an instinctive behavior for your dog, and he has a heightened sense of smell. Peanut butter’s thick and sticky texture is deliciously lickable, and dogs adore its aroma. 

Fortunately, peanuts are also healthy for your dog. They are loaded with protein, vitamin B-6, vitamin E, niacin, and healthy fats. As long as you minimize added sugar, dairy, and salt, peanut butter is a protein-rich snack that is good for your dog.

3,942 People Couldn't Ace This Quiz

Think You Can?

Our 2022 reviews are updated to include the best high-quality peanut butter for your dog.

  1. Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder Bow-Wow Blueberry
  2. Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder Bow-Wow Blueberry
    • A nutritious, simple formula
    • Made in the U.S.A.
    • The first ingredient is unsalted peanuts
    • Contains active prebiotics and probiotics to support your dog's healthy digestive system
    • Includes antioxidant-rich blueberries and honey
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  3. Nutro Crunchy with Real Peanut Butter
  4. Nutro Crunchy with Real Peanut Butter
    • Includes peanut butter, chicken, and oats
    • These crunchy treats contain just 5 calories each
    • Free from chicken by-products, artificial flavors, artificial colors, artificial preservatives, corn, wheat, and soy protein
    • Made in the U.S.A.
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  5. Mount Ara Everyday Wellness Peanut Butter
  6. Mount Ara Everyday Wellness Peanut Butter
    • Contains coconut oil to support your dog's healthy skin, coat, digestive system, and more!
    • Also contains turmeric, a powerful anti-inflammatory that supports joint and bone health
    • Packed with vitamins
    • Free from salt, sugar, milk, and xylitol
    • Great tasting
    Check Chewy
  7. Finley's Barkery Wheat-Free Peanut Butter & Banana
  8. Finley's Barkery Wheat-Free Peanut Butter & Banana
    • The company dedicates 50% of its net profits to initiatives that empower people with disabilities
    • Made in the U.S.A. from human-grade food
    • Free from fillers, wheat, corn, soy, and chemical preservatives
    • Good for your dog's digestion
    • Help to clean teeth and freshen breath
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  9. Buddy Biscuits Grain-Free Soft & Chewy with Peanut Butter
  10. Buddy Biscuits Grain-Free Soft & Chewy with Peanut Butter
    • These bone-shaped treats are grain and gluten-free
    • Made from human-grade, non-GMO ingredients sourced in the U.S.
    • Light, crunchy texture
    • Free from artificial flavors, colors, and fillers
    • Perfect for dogs with food allergies or sensitivities
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  11. Portland Pet Food Company Pumpkin Biscuits
  12. Portland Pet Food Company Pumpkin Biscuits
    • Its light, crunchy texture is satisfying, but easy enough for dogs with chewing issues to eat
    • Gluten-free and grain-free
    • Made from human-grade, non-GMO ingredients
    • Contain garbanzo-bean flour, pumpkin, peanut butter, and more!
    • Free from artificial flavors, colorings, and fillers
    Check Chewy

1. Overall Best Peanut Butter for Your Dog: Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder Bow-Wow Blueberry Probiotic & Prebiotic Peanut Butter Lickable Dog Treat

In our review, the overall best peanut butter for your dog is Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder Bow-Wow Blueberry Probiotic & Prebiotic Peanut Butter Lickable Dog Treat for its nutritious, simple formula and lickable result. Bark Bistro’s peanut butter is made in the USA, and the first ingredient is unsalted peanuts, making it a healthy snack for dogs of any age. 

If you read the ingredient list of many of the lickable peanut butter products on the market, they include things like milk, sugar, and salt, which are not beneficial to your dog’s long-term health and are easy to overdo. Bark Bistro’s peanut butter avoids those extra ingredients and contains active prebiotics and probiotics to support your furry friend’s healthy digestive system.

The added blueberries and honey give your dog a boost of antioxidants. This pure supplement is free of sugar, soy, wheat, additives, and byproducts.

Overall Best
Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder Bow-Wow Blueberry
  • A nutritious, simple formula
  • Made in the U.S.A.
  • The first ingredient is unsalted peanuts
  • Contains active prebiotics and probiotics to support your dog's healthy digestive system
  • Includes antioxidant-rich blueberries and honey
Check Chewy Check Amazon

2. Best to Support Your Dog’s Joints and Bones: Mount Ara Everyday Wellness Peanut Butter for Dogs 

Mount Ara’s peanut butter formula includes coconut oil and turmeric. Coconut oil (in small amounts) is healthy for your dog’s skin, coat, digestive system, cognitive function, and immune system

It also includes turmeric, which is an effective anti-inflammatory that supports bone and joint health. So this great-tasting peanut butter spread is packed with vitamins and supports your dog’s well-being.

The all-natural formula is free of ingredients like salt, sugar, milk, or xylitol. Instead, it’s a tasty treat that is great for your pet. With so many potent supplements like folic acid, coconut oil, and turmeric, you’ll want to limit how much of this treat you feed to your pet to a couple of spoonfuls a day.

Best Joint & Bone Support
Mount Ara Everyday Wellness Peanut Butter
  • Contains coconut oil to support your dog's healthy skin, coat, digestive system, and more!
  • Also contains turmeric, a powerful anti-inflammatory that supports joint and bone health
  • Packed with vitamins
  • Free from salt, sugar, milk, and xylitol
  • Great tasting
Check Chewy

3. Best Peanut Butter Treats With Chicken: NUTRO Small Crunchy Natural Dog Treats With Real Peanut Butter

NUTRO Crunchy dog treats add the fan-favorite of peanut butter with chicken and oats for a burst of flavor full of nutrition. These crunchy treats are suitable for small and large dogs and deliver lots of high-quality protein with only five calories a treat.

NUTRO Crunchy dog biscuits are free of chicken by-products, artificial flavors or colors, artificial preservatives, corn, wheat, or soy protein. They are proudly made in the USA in Joplin, Missouri.

Best Peanut Butter Treats with Chicken
Nutro Crunchy with Real Peanut Butter
  • Includes peanut butter, chicken, and oats
  • These crunchy treats contain just 5 calories each
  • Free from chicken by-products, artificial flavors, artificial colors, artificial preservatives, corn, wheat, and soy protein
  • Made in the U.S.A.
Check Chewy Check Amazon

4. Best Peanut Butter Treats With Pumpkin: Portland Pet Food Company Pumpkin Biscuits Grain-Free & Gluten-Free Dog Treats

These crunchy bone-shaped treats are grain and gluten-free and made from human-grade non-GMO ingredients sourced in the United States. It’s great for dogs with food allergies or sensitivities or who are on a grain-free diet to lose weight.

Portland Pet Food Company double bakes these treats to create a light, crunchy texture that delivers a satisfying texture that is still easy for dogs that have chewing challenges to eat.

These high-quality treats are free of artificial flavors, colorings, and fillers. They contain garbanzo-bean flour, pumpkin, peanut butter, molasses (for a touch of nutritious sweetness), and cinnamon. Don’t get confused! They are for your dog!

Best Peanut Butter Treats With Pumpkin
Portland Pet Food Company Pumpkin Biscuits
  • Its light, crunchy texture is satisfying, but easy enough for dogs with chewing issues to eat
  • Gluten-free and grain-free
  • Made from human-grade, non-GMO ingredients
  • Contain garbanzo-bean flour, pumpkin, peanut butter, and more!
  • Free from artificial flavors, colorings, and fillers
Check Chewy

5. Best Socially Responsible Peanut Butter Treat: Finley’s Peanut Butter & Banana Dog Biscuits Treats for Dogs

Not only does Finley’s make nutrient-packed treats that dogs love, but it also dedicates 50% of its net profits to community empowerment initiatives that offer support to people with disabilities and help them get jobs. That’s a lot of good in a bag of treats.

The biscuits are made in the USA with human-grade foods like oats, peanut butter, banana, and coconut oil. There is no wheat, corn, soy, extra fillers, or chemical preservatives. They are good for your dog’s digestion and work with a limited ingredient diet. 

With ingredients sourced from local and community-based farmers or sustainable suppliers, Finley’s makes a treat you can feel great about giving your dog and buying. The biscuits are crunchy, tasty, nutritious, and allergy-friendly.

Since they are crunchy, they have some added benefit of reducing the tartar build-up on your dog’s teeth and can help freshen his breath. The size is suitable for both small and large dogs.

Best Socially Responsible
Finley's Barkery Wheat-Free Peanut Butter & Banana
  • The company dedicates 50% of its net profits to initiatives that empower people with disabilities
  • Made in the U.S.A. from human-grade food
  • Free from fillers, wheat, corn, soy, and chemical preservatives
  • Good for your dog's digestion
  • Help to clean teeth and freshen breath
Check Chewy Check Amazon

6. Best Soft and Chewy Peanut Butter Biscuits: Buddy Biscuits Grain-Free Soft & Chewy with Peanut Butter Dog Treats

Buddy’s chewy, grain-free treats are baked in fun ginger-kid shapes, a cute and tasty treat. Made from simple, wholesome ingredients, they are suitable for big and small dogs with food allergies or sensitive tummies.

The soft and chewy texture is good for dogs who have difficulty chewing. The treats are made in the USA and are free of grains, corn, soy, artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives. 

They do have some pea and potato flour, which is not ideal for some dogs because they don’t add much nutrition. However, they also contain flaxseeds which add omega fatty acids that are healthy for your skin and coat. 

Best Soft and Chewy
Buddy Biscuits Grain-Free Soft & Chewy with Peanut Butter
  • These bone-shaped treats are grain and gluten-free
  • Made from human-grade, non-GMO ingredients sourced in the U.S.
  • Light, crunchy texture
  • Free from artificial flavors, colors, and fillers
  • Perfect for dogs with food allergies or sensitivities
Check Chewy Check Amazon

Choosing the Best: What to Look For

When choosing the best peanut butter for your dog, there are three factors you will want to consider. Specifically:

  • Is there added salt, sugar, or milk?
  • Does the texture match what you need?
  • Does it contain xylitol or chocolate?

Is There Added Salt, Sugar, or Milk?

Most dogs can eat some salt, sugar, and milk without negative consequences, so this is not a do-or-die criterion, but they aren’t healthy for your dog, and it’s best to avoid them when possible. Many of the most popular peanut kinds of butter for dogs contain milk or sugar. Most peanut butter made for humans includes salt.

Does the Texture Match What You Need?

If you are serving your dog peanut butter on a spoon, the texture won’t matter much. However, if you have specific toys you are filling with peanut butter, then a texture that is too thick or too runny might be too messy to use or harder to clean up. Some owners get around this by filling the toys with peanut butter and then freezing them, so the texture is nice and thick when they give them to their dogs.

In terms of baked treats, your dog may prefer a crunchy or soft treat, so you want the texture to match.

Does It Contain Xylitol or Chocolate?

Xylitol and chocolate are common ingredients in peanut butter made for humans but they are both toxic to dogs. Xylitol is a sweetener that is low-glycemic and good for human teeth, but in dogs, it pulls water into their intestines and can result in death.

Chocolate is pretty easy to spot and avoid, but if you’re thinking of sharing your favorite peanut butter with your trusty, furry friend, double-check that there is no xylitol before giving her any.

The Different Types of Peanut Butter for Your Dog: Pros and Cons Compared

Peanuts are a healthy snack for dogs, but the red skins around the peanuts inside the shell are not. When you are shopping for peanut butter treats for your pup, there are several types that will work. They include unsalted human peanut butter, peanut butter for dogs, crunchy treats, and soft treats.

Here are some pros and cons of each type.

Unsalted Human Peanut Butter

PROSCONS
Easy to find and buyCan contain xylitol which is deadly to dogs
Can be purely ground-up peanutsMay be made with peanut skins which are not healthy for your dog
Can be more affordable (possibly)

Peanut Butter for Dogs

PROSCONS
Made for dogsMay contain milk, salt, or sugar
Can include helpful supplementsTextures vary
Keeps your food and your dog’s treats separate

Crunchy Treats

PROSCONS
May have some dental hygiene benefitsCan be hard for some dogs to chew
Easy and clean to serve and carryCan have grains, fillers, additives, or preservatives
Can include other sources of protein or added healthy ingredients like pumpkin or banana

Soft Treats

ProsCons
Easy to chewCan have grains, fillers, additives, or preservatives
Easy and clean to serve and carry
Can include other sources of protein or added healthy ingredients like pumpkin or banana

Verified Review: User Experience

Owners who use Kong fillable toys appreciate Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder Bow-Wow Blueberry Probiotic & Prebiotic Peanut Butter because it works in the toys but doesn’t have salt or milk added. Some refrigerate the treat before using it for the toys or fill the toys and then freeze them so the texture is nice and thick when they give the filled toys to their dogs. Other reviews rave that this treat is great for their dogs with sensitive stomachs or who need probiotics and won’t eat the powders. Almost all say their dogs love the taste.

One user of Mount Ara Everyday Wellness Peanut Butter says that even their dog that hates peanut butter loves this treat. Other owners are happy to find a natural treat that is actually healthy and one mentioned she even eats a little herself! One reviewer whose dog was recovering from surgery appreciated the treat’s natural anti-inflammatory properties. Owners who use this peanut butter in the Kong toys recommend filling the toys and then freezing them, so the peanut butter isn’t too runny. 

Reviewers say NUTRO Crunchy Dog Treats with Real Peanut Butter are dog-approved! Both small and large dogs enjoy the crunchy treats, and owners appreciate the small size helps them control how much extra food they are giving to their dogs (we all know that if we don’t stop, they never will). One reviewer reports these are the only treats her German Shepard will eat. She just lets other treats lay there while she waits for NUTRO crunchy dog treats. Another report that he has three dogs who love the treats and his little Jack Russel mix was impossible to train until he got these.

Owners who buy Portland Pet Food Company Pumpkin Biscuits for their pets are amazed at the simple and clean ingredient list. They say the smell when they open the bag is so good they almost want to try one! One reviewer whose Shih-Tzu gets an upset stomach or diarrhea with other treats reports she can eat these up with zero problems. Other owners whose dogs have allergies say they are happy they found something that finally works for their pet. A few dogs turned up their noses, but not every pet likes peanut butter and pumpkin.

One reviewer of Finley’s Barkery Wheat-Free Peanut Butter & Banana Crunchy Biscuit Dog Treats says her dog walks on her hind legs to get these treats. The consensus among both dogs and owners is enthusiastic, even for dogs with allergies or sensitive stomachs. They even work inside a Kong ball! A few users complained that the treats were crumbly and by the end of the bag, there was a lot of dust. A very small number of dogs did not like the treats, but by far, most owners gave the treats five stars.

Owners who purchased Buddy Biscuits Grain-Free Soft & Chewy with Peanut Butter for their dogs report the treats are a perfect size, and most dogs love them. Many owners whose dogs are older and not as comfortable with crunchy treats appreciate how easy these treats are to chew. Many reviewers with picky dogs report their pets love these treats, though there are a few dogs who were not impressed.

About the Author

Joan Weisman is an experienced freelance marketing strategist and copywriter who helps small businesses expand their audience and stay top of mind with customers. She loves animals and dotes on her cat and dog.