The Best Blue Buffalo Cat Food: Reviewed and Ranked

Updated: July 6, 2022

This post may contain affiliate links to our partners like Chewy, Amazon, and others. Purchasing through these helps us further the A-Z Animals mission to educate about the world's species..

Blue Buffalo is a premium pet food brand. On top of their wide range of dog foods, they also have a range of cat food options. This cat food contains high-quality meats and many of its recipes are grain-free.

However, there are some slight differences between all of their cat foods. Some of them feature different meats than others. Therefore, to choose the best option for your cat, it’s best to know your options.

This article dives into the top Blue Buffalo cat foods. We’ll discuss each food separately and help you decide which option is best for your feline.

  1. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
  2. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
    • Features a high protein content
    • The first ingredient is chicken, and it contains both deboned chicken and chicken meal
    • This recipe also includes fish meal, which provides omega-fatty acids
    • It does not contain grains, corn, wheat, or so
    • Features LifeSource Bits, the company's proprietary blend of vitamins and antioxidants
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  3. Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult
  4. Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult
    • Contains high levels of chicken and fish
    • Fish includes omega-fatty acids for skin and coat health
    • Features whole grains, including brown rice, barley, and oatmeal, which contain a wide variety of nutrients
    • Does not include corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or preservatives
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  5. Blue Buffalo Blue Tastefuls Ocean Fish and Tuna Entree Pate Wet Cat Food
  6. Blue Buffalo Blue Tastefuls Ocean Fish and Tuna Entree Pate Wet Cat Food
    • Tuna is the first ingredient, and it's rich in protein
    • It's made with fish broth instead of water for even more nutrition
    • This recipe has a flaky texture that many cats adore
    • The high moisture content will help hydrate cats that don't drink enough water
    • Free from corn, soy, wheat, artificial flavors, and poultry by-product meal
    Check Amazon
  7. Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Salmon, Chicken, Ocean Fish & Tuna Entrées Variety Pack
  8. Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Salmon, Chicken, Ocean Fish & Tuna Entrées Variety Pack
    • This variety pack includes salmon, chicken, and ocean fish flavors
    • Each recipe will provide your cat with rich protein
    • The variety will keep your cat from getting bored with the same flavors
    • Smooth pate recipe
    • Doesn't include corn, soy, wheat, artificial flavors, or preservatives.
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  9. Blue Buffalo Healthy Living Natural Adult Dry Cat Food, Chicken & Brown Rice
  10. Blue Buffalo Healthy Living Natural Adult Dry Cat Food, Chicken & Brown Rice
    • Features deboned chicken and chicken meal for lean protein
    • Includes brown rice, barley, and oatmeal for fiber, energy, vitamins, and minerals
    • This recipe also includes pea protein and peas for protein
    • Supplemented with taurine, an amino acid that is essential for a cat's heart health
    Check Chewy
  11. Blue Buffalo Weight Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food
  12. Blue Buffalo Weight Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food
    • Chicken is the first ingredient in this recipe
    • The recipe also includes whole-grains, such as barley, oatmeal, and brown rice, for energy, fiber, and nutrients
    • Supplemented with omega-fatty acids for your cat's skin and coat health
    • This formula is higher in fiber and lower in calories than most other cat foods, so it's designed to help obese cats lose weight
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  13. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Pate Variety Pack
  14. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Pate Variety Pack
    • High-quality protein is essential for cats
    • Includes flavors like chicken, salmon, and duck
    • Added amino acids
    • No by-product meals, soy, corn, or wheat
    Check Chewy Check Amazon
  15. Blue Buffalo Healthy Growth Kitten Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food
  16. Blue Buffalo Healthy Growth Kitten Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food
    • Formulated for a kitten's specific nutritional needs
    • Kitten foods help kittens to grow
    • Includes chicken and several whole grains
    • Supplemented with LifeSource Bits, which contain the minerals, vitamins, and antioxidants your kitten needs to develop into a healthy cat
    • Free from corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavors, and preservatives
    Check Chewy Check Amazon

1. Best Overall: Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe

My cats find this food to be delicious. It features a high protein content, with chicken as the first ingredient. This food contains both deboned chicken and chicken meal, making it high in protein than most foods out there. Plus, it also includes fish meal, which increases omega fatty acids.

This formula contains no grains and is made without corn, wheat, or soy. However, it does include high levels of peas and pea protein instead. Still, it features more animal protein than most formulas, making it a solid option for most cats.

Like most Blue Buffalo foods, the company added LifeSource Bits to the mixture. These bits contain antioxidants and a unique vitamin blend.

Best Overall
Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
  • Features a high protein content
  • The first ingredient is chicken, and it contains both deboned chicken and chicken meal
  • This recipe also includes fish meal, which provides omega-fatty acids
  • It does not contain grains, corn, wheat, or so
  • Features LifeSource Bits, the company's proprietary blend of vitamins and antioxidants
Check Chewy Check Amazon

2. Best for Indoor Cats: Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Chicken & Brown Rice

This cat food contains high levels of chicken and fish meat. Fish meat includes high levels of omega-fatty acids, vital for coat and skin health.

On top of high amounts of meat, this food contains whole grains. Brown rice, barley, and oatmeal are included. While refined grains don’t offer much nutrition, whole grains include a variety of nutrients.

Plus, this food does not include corn, wheat, or soy. It also doesn’t have any artificial flavors or preservatives. Therefore, it may be better for cats with sensitivities.

Best for Indoor Cats
Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult
  • Contains high levels of chicken and fish
  • Fish includes omega-fatty acids for skin and coat health
  • Features whole grains, including brown rice, barley, and oatmeal, which contain a wide variety of nutrients
  • Does not include corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or preservatives
Check Chewy Check Amazon

3. Best Fish Flavor: Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Tuna Entrée

This Blue Buffalo formula includes tuna as the first ingredient, as the name suggests. It also includes fish broth instead of water, which increases the nutritional content. The tuna included is rich in protein, precisely what cats need to thrive.

Many cats enjoy the flaky texture. However, this feature is very dependent on preference.

Furthermore, this food has an extremely high moisture content. Some cats have trouble drinking enough water, so this wet cat food is perfect for these cats.

Plus, this formula does not contain any lower-quality ingredients. It is free from corn, soy, wheat, and artificial flavors. While it does include some chicken products, there is no poultry by-product meal.

Best Fish Flavor
Blue Buffalo Blue Tastefuls Ocean Fish and Tuna Entree Pate Wet Cat Food
  • Tuna is the first ingredient, and it's rich in protein
  • It's made with fish broth instead of water for even more nutrition
  • This recipe has a flaky texture that many cats adore
  • The high moisture content will help hydrate cats that don't drink enough water
  • Free from corn, soy, wheat, artificial flavors, and poultry by-product meal
Check Amazon

4. Best Variety Pack: Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Salmon, Chicken, Ocean Fish & Tuna Variety Pack

This variety pack includes three different flavors, including salmon, chicken, and ocean fish. All of these ingredients provide your cat with rich protein. Plus, because there are so many options available, your cat won’t grow tired of the same flavor over and over again.

Unlike other wet foods on this list, this option features a smooth texture. Therefore, if your cat doesn’t like chunkier textures, this food may be suitable.

Like most Blue Buffalo foods, this recipe does not contain corn, soy, or wheat. Plus, it is free from artificial flavors and preservatives.

Best Variety Pack
Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Salmon, Chicken, Ocean Fish & Tuna Entrées Variety Pack
  • This variety pack includes salmon, chicken, and ocean fish flavors
  • Each recipe will provide your cat with rich protein
  • The variety will keep your cat from getting bored with the same flavors
  • Smooth pate recipe
  • Doesn't include corn, soy, wheat, artificial flavors, or preservatives.
Check Chewy Check Amazon

5. Best for UTI Prevention: Blue Buffalo Wilderness Pate Variety Pack Duck, Chicken & Salmon

This variety pack includes 12 different cans of three ounces each. With a smooth texture, this Blue Buffalo wet food may be suitable for cats that are pickier. Many picky cats seem to prefer the smoother texture.

All recipes include meat as the first few ingredients. Broth is also used instead of water, improving the nutritional content. We also liked that these recipes include plenty of animal organ meat. For instance, most of them include chicken liver, which is high in a variety of vitamins.

Of course, this wet food contains more water. Therefore, we recommend it for cats that are prone to urinary tract problems or other dehydration-linked illnesses.

Best High Protein
Blue Buffalo Wilderness Pate Variety Pack
  • High-quality protein is essential for cats
  • Includes flavors like chicken, salmon, and duck
  • Added amino acids
  • No by-product meals, soy, corn, or wheat
Check Chewy Check Amazon

6. Best for Seniors: Blue Buffalo Healthy Aging Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe

This recipe starts with deboned chicken and chicken meal. Chicken is an extremely common cat food ingredient that provides lean protein. As a grain-inclusive formula, you’ll also find brown rice, barley, and oatmeal on the recipe list. These whole grains provide added fiber and some vitamins and minerals.

However, you’ll also find pea protein and peas on the ingredient list. These veggie ingredients contain a lot of protein, which is likely why they are included. Keep this in mind when you’re looking at the protein content of this food.

We like that taurine is added for heart health. While this amino acid is vital for a healthy heart, this ingredient usually isn’t found in cat food.

Best for Seniors
Blue Buffalo Healthy Living Natural Adult Dry Cat Food, Chicken & Brown Rice
  • Features deboned chicken and chicken meal for lean protein
  • Includes brown rice, barley, and oatmeal for fiber, energy, vitamins, and minerals
  • This recipe also includes pea protein and peas for protein
  • Supplemented with taurine, an amino acid that is essential for a cat's heart health
Check Chewy

7. Best for Overweight Cats: Blue Buffalo Weight Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe

As the name suggests, this food contains chicken as the first ingredient. Chicken contains a lot of protein, which is vital for cats. In fact, cats need quite a bit of protein to thrive, as they are obligate carnivores.

You’ll also find whole-grain ingredients in this recipe. For instance, barley, oatmeal, and brown rice appear pretty early on the ingredient list. While too much grain isn’t necessarily a good thing, whole grain includes a high amount of fiber and nutrients.

Omega fatty acids have been added to this recipe. These acids improve skin and coat health, so it may be best for cats with underlying skin conditions.

Furthermore, this food contains a higher fiber content than most options foods, so it may keep your cat full for longer. It is also lower in calories than your average food. In this way, feeding this to your cat may help them lose weight.

Best for Overweight Cats
Blue Buffalo Weight Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food
  • Chicken is the first ingredient in this recipe
  • The recipe also includes whole-grains, such as barley, oatmeal, and brown rice, for energy, fiber, and nutrients
  • Supplemented with omega-fatty acids for your cat's skin and coat health
  • This formula is higher in fiber and lower in calories than most other cat foods, so it's designed to help obese cats lose weight
Check Chewy Check Amazon

8. Best for Kittens: Blue Buffalo Healthy Growth Chicken & Brown Rice

Kittens need very specific nutrition to grow properly. Adult cat food simply helps maintain a cat’s current weight. However, kittens are currently growing, so they need more than just maintenance food.

For this reason, feeding your kitten a kitten food like this one is vital for their growth.

Like most foods on this list, this recipe includes chicken and a variety of whole grains. All of these ingredients are a great option for kittens, as they provide the nutrients they need to grow.

LifeSource Bits are also included in this food. These bits contain minerals, vitamins, and antioxidants that help your kitten grow into a healthy cat.

You also won’t find any corn, wheat, or soy in this formula. Plus, it’s from free artificial flavors and preservatives.

Best for Kittens
Blue Buffalo Healthy Growth Kitten Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food
  • Formulated for a kitten's specific nutritional needs
  • Kitten foods help kittens to grow
  • Includes chicken and several whole grains
  • Supplemented with LifeSource Bits, which contain the minerals, vitamins, and antioxidants your kitten needs to develop into a healthy cat
  • Free from corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavors, and preservatives
Check Chewy Check Amazon

Choosing the Best: What to Look For

Not all cat foods contain the same ingredients – even when they are made by the same company. To choose the best Blue Buffalo foods for your cat, you need to keep nutrition, ingredients, life stage, and special dietary needs.

Let’s take a look at each of these aspects below.

Nutrition

Cats need very specific nutrition – just like any other animal. Because cats are obligate carnivores, they eat a lot of protein. Therefore, most Blue Buffalo foods start with a meat ingredient.

Beyond protein, though, the exact amino acids and fatty acids matter. Of course, the vitamin and mineral content matters quite a bit, too.

You’ll need to consider each food’s nutritional profile to choose one for your cat.

Ingredients

All cat foods will have slightly different ingredients. While most ingredients work for the majority of cats, some cats may be unable to consume certain ingredients. For instance, food allergies can affect a cat’s dietary needs.

Of course, beyond your cat’s specific needs, you should choose the highest quality ingredients available. Look for high amounts of meat, whole grains, and a suitable amount of veggies.

Life Stage

Cats need different nutrition at different ages. For instance, you’ll need to feed cats kitten food while they are growing. Adult cats need adult maintenance food.

When it comes to senior cat food, there is not a specific age when you have to start feeding your cat senior food. However, many senior foods include vitamins and ingredients that cats may benefit from if they have common problems associated with old age.

Special Dietary Needs

Not all cats have the same dietary needs. For instance, some of them may have specific health conditions that require a special diet. Allergies are the most common example of this.

If your cat falls into this category, be sure to choose a food that is suitable for them.

The Different Types of Blue Buffalo Cat Food: Pros and Cons Compared

There are two main types of Blue Buffalo Cat Food — wet and dry. Each of these options is slightly different. Remember that you don’t necessarily have to choose one or the other. Many people mix wet and dry cat food.

  • Dry cat food – The most common cat food. It usually comes in a bag and has a long shelf life, which is one reason it is so popular.
  • Wet cat food – This food comes in a can or a pouch and has a high water content. It is often considered to be a better option for most cats.

Dry Cat Food

ProsCons
Less expensiveLow moisture content
Long shelf lifeMay cause obesity
More convenientOften contains more grains
Allows for free-feeding
Can be used in puzzle toys

Wet Cat Food

ProsCons
High water contentMore expensive
Suitable for some common illnessesShort shelf life
Very palatable
More suitable for picky eaters
Prevents owners from free-feeding

Verified Reviews: Users’ Experiences

Blue Buffalo food often has great reviews. As a meat-based food, many felines prefer this food over others. Plus, it also provides a complete line of foods for kittens through seniors.

There is a lot of praise for this cat food. Many are happy with their quality ingredients, as they are very meat-heavy.

One of the only complaints about this food is its price. As a premium option, it is more expensive than many other foods. Furthermore, some of the recipes (like Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken) contain more calories than others. Therefore, they may cause weight gain.