American Robin vs Oriole: What’s the difference?

Written by Jeremiah Wright
Published: August 24, 2022
Share on:

Advertisement


The American robin and oriole are both migratory songbirds often mistaken for one another because of their orange breasts. In addition to their striking appearance, both orioles and American robins naturally nest in dense deciduous trees or bushes, usually above the ground, and are built by the females alone. Both species spawn in spring and are also omnivores. Their diets consist mainly of insects, fruits, and berries.

The American robins and orioles are also most active during the day. During winter, they assemble in large flocks at night to roost in trees located in dense vegetation or secluded swamps.

Although they are very similar, both species have distinct features that can help you figure out which is which. This article addresses 8 key differences between the American robin and the oriole to help you discern between the two birds.

43,527 People Couldn't Ace This Quiz

Think You Can?

Comparing American Robin vs Oriole

The American robin and oriole are both migratory songbirds often mistaken for one another because of their orange breasts.
Key DifferencesAmerican RobinOriole
Scientific classificationBirds of the true thrush genus Turdus, family TurdidaeBirds of the Old World genus Oriolus, family Oriolidae, or
Birds in the New World genus Icterus, family Icteridae
Size and shapeLength: 8 to 11 inches (20 to 27.9 cm)
Weight: 2.65 to 2.7 oz (75 to 77 g)
Length: 7.8 to 9.4 inches (20 to 24 cm)
Weight- 0.5 to 0.7 oz (15 to 20 g)
Colors and variationsGray, black, orange, whiteBlack, yellow, brown, orange, white
Distribution and habitatInhabit woodland and shrublands throughout most of North AmericaInhabit woodland and forests in the Nearctic, including many parts of Central Asia, Canada, and the United States
Flights and songsMales exhibit complex and almost continuous songs often described as cheery carolMales sing a loud flutey sound
Clutch size3 to 5 light blue eggs4 to 5 eggs
Mating behaviorIn addition to dancing for the female, males lure their partners using tasty bits of foodMales sing and chatter while hopping from perch to perch in front of the female, trying to lure her
Life span2 yearsUp to 12 years in the wild

8 Key Differences Between an American Robin and Oriole

The key differences between the American robin and the oriole are their sizes, color variations, as well as vocalizations, among others.

With relatively rounded bodies, American robins are larger than orioles. Besides that, American robins have an average lifespan of two years, while orioles may live up to 12 years in the wild.

Let’s discuss all of these differences in more detail.

American Robin vs Oriole: Scientific Classification

What Do Robins Eat

There are seven recognized subspecies of the American robin.

©iStock.com/Mason Maron

The American robin belongs to the true thrush genus Turdus and the family Turdidae, the wider thrush family. There are seven recognized subspecies of American robin which intergrade with each other. They include:

  • The eastern robin
  • The southern robin
  • The Newfoundland robin
  • The northwestern robin
  • The western robin
  • The Mexican robin
  • The San Lucas robin

Orioles can either be any of the 30 species of birds that belong to the New World genus Icterus, family Icteridae, or belong to the Old World, any of the 30 species of genus Oreolus, family Oriolidae. Both are families of perching birds of the order Passeriformes. 

American Robin vs Oriole: Size and Shape

oriole perched at end of stick

Orioles are medium-sized passerines, around 7.8 to 9.4 inches in length.

©iStock.com/phototrip

American robins are slightly larger than orioles. They have round bodies, long legs, and fairly long tails. An adult American robin weighs between 8 to 11 inches (20 to 27.9 cm) and weighs approximately 2.65 to 2.7 oz (75 to 77 g).

Orioles are medium-sized passerines, around 7.8 to 9.4 inches (20 to 24 cm) in length. Females are slightly smaller than males, although the size dimorphism is minimal by icterid standards. An adult oriole weighs about 0.5 to 0.7 oz (15 to 20g). 

American Robin vs Oriole: Colors and Variations

American robin eating a berry

American robins have gray-brown plumage with dark heads and orange underparts.

©iStock.com/mirceax

American robins have gray-brown plumage with dark heads and orange underparts. They have a white patch under their tail and along their belly that is conspicuous when in flight. Their bills are relatively yellow with a variably dark tip. Their legs and feet are brown. Although American robins don’t exhibit sexual dimorphism, females tend to be duller than males.

Orioles vary in color across species. Most of them have bright and showy plumage, though females have duller plumage compared to males. For example, the male Golden oriole has a striking yellow and jet black plumage, while the females are more dull-looking and slightly greener in color. 

In Baltimore orioles, males have a complete black plumage and deep flaming orange underparts, while females are yellow-brown on the upper parts with darker wings and dull orange-yellow breasts.

American Robin vs Oriole: Distribution and Habitat

American robins inhabit woodlands, shrublands, and suburban park yards. Most American robins migrate to winter south of Canada, from Florida and the Gulf Coast to central Mexico. In contrast, others occasionally winter in the southern parts of Canada and northern parts of the United States. They breed throughout most parts of North America- from northern Florida and Mexico to southward Alaska and Canada.

Orioles are distributed across Australia, Europe, Africa, and North America. Some species of oriole, including the Baltimore, are found in the Nearctic during summer. During winter, Baltimore orioles migrate as far north as Mexico and partly to the southern coast of the United States. Some parts of the southern United States may retain many oriole species if they have feeders that appeal to them.

American Robin vs Oriole: Flights and Songs

Like many thrushes, the male American robin has a complex and almost continuous vocalization. The song is described as a cheery melody made of discrete units, often continuous, with brief pauses in between. On the contrary, most male species of oriole utter pure, liquid, whistling sounds that have a full, flutelike tone.

American Robin vs Oriole: Clutch Size

Yellow Animal – Eurasian golden oriole

Female orioles lay between 4 and 5 eggs.

©iStock.com/phototrip

The average clutch size of American robins is between 3 to 5 light blue eggs incubated by females alone. The incubation period lasts roughly 14 days, and the chicks leave the nest two weeks after hatching. The chicks are naked for the first few days after hatching and have their eyes closed.

Unlike American robins, female orioles lay between 4 and 5 eggs. The eggs hatch after 12 to 14 days. Once the nestlings hatch, both parents feed them by regurgitation. The females are in charge of brooding the chicks until two weeks. The chicks start to fledge at two weeks and become largely independent shortly after.

American Robin vs Oriole: Mating Behavior

Both American robins and orioles sing loudly and dance to lure the females. However, in addition to dancing, when a partner has been found, a male American robin brings his partner tasty bits of food to strengthen the pair’s bond. 

On the other hand, male orioles try to attract their mating partners by singing and chattering continuously as they hop from perch to perch in front of her while giving a bow display (bowing with fanned and wings lowered) to lure her.

American Robin vs Oriole: Lifespan

American robins have an average lifespan of 2 years. On the contrary, the average lifespan varies among oriole species, but most live up to 12 years in the wild and about 14 years in captivity. 

American robins and orioles are vulnerable to predation from hawks, snakes, cats, and other large birds. Predation is a common source of mortality among adults, nestlings, and fledglings, typically also occurring with eggs.

The photo featured at the top of this post is © John L. Absher/Shutterstock.com


Share on:
About the Author

I hold seven years of professional experience in the content world, focusing on nature, and wildlife. Asides from writing, I enjoy surfing the internet and listening to music.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us? Contact the AZ Animals editorial team.